• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Favorite Ice Cream?

Which do you prefer?

  • Frozen Custard

    Votes: 26 19.0%
  • Ice Cream

    Votes: 98 71.5%
  • Neither

    Votes: 13 9.5%

  • Total voters
    137
Ice cream, gelato, frozen custard, sorbet?
You ask me the difference; choose your sobriquet.

Some are made thinly, others too thickly,
eat yours too fast and your tummy feels sickly.

There's no mention of sherbert - is this treat so hated?
Or shall tapioca pudding today be berated?

Democrats, 'Publicans, Libertarian centrists,
after endulging in these all see their dentists.

I have to lie down now. :D

Mike ;)
 
Lowrez is right...partially.

Nomenclature aside, frozen custard is basically any ice cream made "new york" style, which is an ice cream made with a tempered egg mixture. Ice creams made "Philadelphia" style have no egg in them whatsoever, and aren't usually scalded beforehand, and therefore do not qualify to be a frozen custard.

I believe what the thread is addressing though really is the difference between soft serve and regular scooped ice cream.

Oh, and if you need any further clarifications, I can help. I did go to school for an associates degree in pastry, so food is one of my passions.
 
Kronos said:
Lowrez is right...partially.

Nomenclature aside, frozen custard is basically any ice cream made "new york" style, which is an ice cream made with a tempered egg mixture. Ice creams made "Philadelphia" style have no egg in them whatsoever, and aren't usually scalded beforehand, and therefore do not qualify to be a frozen custard.

I believe what the thread is addressing though really is the difference between soft serve and regular scooped ice cream.

Oh, and if you need any further clarifications, I can help. I did go to school for an associates degree in pastry, so food is one of my passions.

Yes & no. I don't consider McDonald's soft serve ice cream as custard. To me there is a difference. I can make soft serve ice cream at home in the microwave.
 
addylewis said:
FROZEN CUSTARD?! - ZUH?!

Sounds bloody horrible... now LEMON SORBET on the other hand, I know the stuff,and its better than any ice cream I've ever had!
Well, sometimes a word that brits use to describe one thing means a completely different thing on this side of the pond. I don't think it's the same kind of custard you're thinking of.

That said, i refuse to vote until I get a sample of this thing you say is a match to ice cream.

It takes a heck of a dessert to make me not want Dreyer's Almond Praline. I swear, that must be what frozen angel poop tastes like.

Yes, I know I'm weird. ;)