Thanks for sharing your experience! I know what you mean about the feel of a CS. My CS '60 Jazz Bass is superior to the other J-Basses I own in that regard. (It sounds great, too.)I guess I'm a little late to the party. I can't swear the CS's sound better, but, in general, they always seem to sound better and smoother even with the non-hand wound CS pickups. The two CS P's I have and three CS J's I previously had never had any dead spots or weak sounding G strings. I will say emphatically that they "feel" worlds better. However, if the P Bass you have now sounds and feels good to you, keep it.