• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Fender Precision pickup question

For waking up a "tame" P-Bass, my favourite pickup is the DiMarzio Split-P.
It's a significant upgrade, yet not very expensive. I always try to get the black pickup covers, I don't like the white ones.

Split P™ | DiMarzio
I saw a really good comparison vid over on youtube about the Split P vs the Model P and I gotta say, the Model P still sounded like a real P but the Split P made it sound...modern. Humbucker-y? I can’t explain it with words enough.
Here it is:

 
  • Like
Reactions: TN WOODMAN
I saw a really good comparison vid over on youtube about the Split P vs the Model P and I gotta say, the Model P still sounded like a real P but the Split P made it sound...modern. Humbucker-y? I can’t explain it with words enough.
Here it is:



I've had the Model P in a few basses in the past. To me, it's got a dirtier sound. Almost a grind to the tone that doesn't dial out with the tone control. But still not as brash as the Will Power.

The Split P is actually a dual-humbucker. So there's some phase issues going on where the Model P doesn't have those. That can create a slightly modern tone to the pickup as it cancels some frequencies out by design. But, it's still a loud pickup - and quite far away from polite.

The other option would be the Will Power pickup. It's perfectly usable on its own but it's even louder, and "throaty." I'm not even a heavy rock player, but I find these pickups all work well for people who have a light touch in their plucking hand. Notes seem to leap out more easily, and there's just enough grind in there to give you "tone" with that light touch.
 
  • Like
Reactions: StevieMac
Is there a replacement pickup that will give me both an aggressive tone, think Dave Hope of Kansas, and a nice funk tone, a tone like "forget me nots" by Patrice Rushen ?

I have a nice Fender Precision, Ocean Turquoise, Maple neck, sets up and plays really well, but it seems like the tone is very bland and lifeless.. I'm currently using Dunlop Superbrights, .45 - .105

I have other individual basses that will do the job, but I'd really like to get more out of this Precision.
I’m not sure what will do it, but the goal to get tone like Dave Hope is an excellent goal.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TN WOODMAN
It's called a treble tone knob: boost and use a pick to get aggressive; roll down and use fingers for grooving.

Well, my choices precluded active circuitry. If you're going to go active, you might as well step into something like an EMG PCSX pickup with either the Active Tone Control kit or one of the B64EQ control sets. That'll screech and groan until the cows come home.
 
I've had a Dimarzio model P pickup in one bass or another for about 40 years now. Still, I don't think the pickup is anywhere near the majority of the tone of a good P bass - the fingers playing it, the strings, and the rig it's hooked up to will vary things much more than most pickup swaps can ever hope to do.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TN WOODMAN
just a pic of recent build ... for the creme 70's vibe thing ...
20200111_154327.jpg
 
Dimarzio DP122. I have two P's with the original Dimarzio PAF's. Very similar to the DP122 (Model P). I also have a P with EMG's which has a tendency to be a little darker sounding. The "Dave Hope" sound is easily acquired with these, some round wounds and a pick. Creme is my favorite color for these.
The Model P PAFs rule. Turned my Mendel Signature into a gnarly vintage tone monster! The new ones allegedly sound exactly the same.. Highly recommended.
DA7C03EB-9C75-4E01-B72C-E7F09AC3EEAA.jpeg
 
I bought a 2013 USA Lakland "Bob Glaub" precision here on TB last fall and the previous owner had dropped some Fralins in there. Not sure, but I suspect they were overwound. While they sounded fantastic for that super thuddy, 200Hz focused sound, from my personal experience with them, they are not the tone you are after. They are strong at 200Hz and 800Hz, but were lacking clarity in the upper registers.

I dropped a Moollon pickup in there a few days ago and its everything I ever wanted this bass to be. With this pickup you could get 70s P slap all day. That said, I remember reading that Freddy had an EMG in there back in the day.
 
Love that bass- just getting GASsy looking at it- I don’t have “just a pbass”...
That would look great with cream covers-
My vote is for the DiMarzio Model P. Can get funky, and still get you to the vintage tone you want- that’s where a preamp/DI box can help get you there when you’re “almost” there...
Just for looks- cream pickups, that maple fretboard would really pop with some black nylon tapewounds!!