This is going to far out question because these amps are quite different from each other especially in terms of price and function, but I wanna put it out there anyway. I’m looking to replace my small gig amp, an early 2000’s Peavey Basic 112 with more powerful, tone packed rig. For my medium to large gigs I’ve got an Ampeg V-4B with 212AV cab. I’m in a classic rocknroll cover band and I’m looking for something that can do small to medium gigs, have more tone than the Peavey, more power of course but still be able to dial down and sound good. I do like the sound of 15s. I’ve never owned a 210 setup. Just a couple 410s at one point. I have played the Rumble 200C and was pretty impressed. I’ve never tried the 500C. I’ve never tried the Mesa’s but have read great things about them. What initially got me looking at the mesa’s was I was looking for a small peg combo or solid state portaflex setup and the folks on here highly recommended the Mesas over the PF solid state amps. $2000 for a Mesa setup over 5-600 for the rumble combos is a hard pill to swallow but is it worth it? How about tone? Between the Mesa WD-800 and the Rumbles which could dig down into classic Peg territory more? Which could get into geezer butler tone in old school sabbath more?