• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Get off my LAWN! "Grumpy Old Farts"

Status
Not open for further replies.
Sounds like a good folk song.

IMG_20191217_125241.jpg
 
Do you ever have to update songs to keep them current? Vaping in the Gender Neutral Restroom Facilities comes to mind.


Politically correct is not a consideration. A song is what it is, either do it or not.

Some female performers will change girl to boy in a lyric. That isn't a big deal but I think that it changes the song in a negative way. If you don't like it as written, I say, write your own song.

Having said that, writers submit songs to record companies that are sometimes later changed and rearranged once assigned to a producer. This is more about extending the writing process and is often done. This should be in consultation with the song's owner.

Parodies are legal. People like Weird Al ask for permission and have been turned down.
 
Last edited:
Never! Politically correct is not a consideration. A song is what it is, either do it or not.

Some female performers will change girl to boy in a lyric. That isn't a big deal but I think that it changes the song in a negative way. If you don't like it as written, I say, write your own song.

Having said that, writers submit songs to record companies that are sometimes later changed and rearranged once assigned to a producer. This is more about extending the writing process and is often done. This should be in consultation with the song's owner.

Parodies are legal. People like Weird Al ask for permission and have been turned down.
One of the songs I do in our group is "6 Days on the Road". There's a line in there: "I just passed a 'Jimmy'[that's a GMC]and a White"-2 prominent big truck* makers at the time. I changed it to "a Mack and a White". GMC's been outta the big truck market for 20+ years.

* as in tractor/trailer
 
One of the songs I do in our group is "6 Days on the Road". There's a line in there: "I just passed a 'Jimmy'[that's a GMC]and a White"-2 prominent big truck* makers at the time. I changed it to "a Mack and a White". GMC's been outta the big truck market for 20+ years.

* as in tractor/trailer

That fits well. Not all changes do as you said earlier.

Comedy can work as well. People mishear words in songs. John Fogerty sings "There's a bathroom on the right" as a joke, see 1:55. The audiences love it. Some think those ARE the words.

 
That fits well. Not all changes do as you said earlier.

Comedy can work as well. People mishear words in songs. John Fogerty sings "There's a bathroom on the right" as a joke, see 1:55. The audiences love it. Some think those ARE the words.


We announce that song as "giving directions to the restroom".
 
That fits well. Not all changes do as you said earlier.

Comedy can work as well. People mishear words in songs. John Fogerty sings "There's a bathroom on the right" as a joke, see 1:55. The audiences love it. Some think those ARE the words.



I cannot un-know that now!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.