- Oct 22, 2015
- 21,166
- 256,980
- Disclosures
- I am an affiliate for Ari Cap.
Of McCartney's songs, I'm given to understand the band unanimously despised Maxwell's Silver Hammer.
TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
Join free Log in
Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.
It's a shame that Paul McCartney didn't show up for this. Go back to his old stomping grounds and play some songs with the rest of the gang.
Of McCartney's songs, I'm given to understand the band unanimously despised Maxwell's Silver Hammer.
Was that before or after Steve Martin did his unheralded version of the song?Of McCartney's songs, I'm given to understand the band unanimously despised Maxwell's Silver Hammer.

Of McCartney's songs, I'm given to understand the band unanimously despised Maxwell's Silver Hammer.
Was that before or after Steve Martin did his unheralded version of the song?![]()
So, was it Ringo, or actually Mal Evans, who "played" the anvil on "Maxwell's..."?
.
Mal. As a roadie, he was the only one with a hammer. Apparently Ringo didn’t have the strength to hit the anvil.
Musical contributions
Evans contributed to many recordings,[3] including singing in the chorus of "Yellow Submarine". He played single organ notes on "You Won't See Me",[3] and harmonica on "Being for the Benefit of Mr. Kite!"[40] McCartney explained that he showed Evans where the notes were on the organ, and then nodded his head when he wanted Evans to play, and shook it when he wanted him to stop.[41]
On "A Day in the Life", Evans controlled an alarm clock; counting the measures in the original 24-bar pause,[13] and was one of the five piano players simultaneously hitting the last chord of the song.[41] He played tambourine on "Dear Prudence", and trumpet on "Helter Skelter", where he played a double solo with Lennon, even though neither was proficient on the instrument.[42] Evans contributed background vocals, and stirred a bucket of gravel (as part of the rhythm), on "You Know My Name (Look Up The Number)".[41] He also contributed to the White Album out-take "What's the New Mary Jane", and hit an anvil on "Maxwell's Silver Hammer",[3][41][43] because Starr could not lift the hammer high enough to get the right sound and keep in time with the song.[43]
The sixth Beatle? Cool trivia.![]()
Was he there with the Beatles at the Iron Door from 1960-1962?He was there from the very beginning at the cavern club. And in the end, he made £38-a-week pay.
Not any longer!Wow - I totally missed that. Never heard Steve's version...

Nice!NCAMBCD
View attachment 4077062
View attachment 4077063
I ordered this from our local Amish furniture store. Based on a L. & J.G. Stickley bookcase from the 1910s, I had it made to custom dimensions to fit a spot in the new enclosed porch, and did away with the ached aprons that the original has.
Here is an original from back in the century.
View attachment 4077070
Thanks for the eyes!Nice!
edit to arched.
Surprised my tired eyes caught it. Still waiting on exam for glasses after cataract surgery...Thanks for the eyes!

He was there from the very beginning at the cavern club. And in the end, he made £38-a-week pay.

Was he there with the Beatles at the Iron Door from 1960-1962?
Not any longer!
NCAMBCD
View attachment 4077062
View attachment 4077063
44" W x 36" H x 10" D
I ordered this from our local Amish furniture store. Based on a L. & J.G. Stickley bookcase from the 1910s, I had it made to custom dimensions to fit a spot in the new enclosed porch, and did away with the arched aprons that the original has.
Here is an original from back in the century.
View attachment 4077070
36" W x 30" H x 12" D
Was he there with the Beatles at the Iron Door from 1960-1962?