Enjoy the benefits of a premium membership!
Upgrade Account
-
TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
Join free Log in
Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.
Good Punk Bass?
- Thread starter LeChickenNug
- Start date
-
- Tags
- punk
With a budget of $850, go out and get a few Squier Affinity P-basses from your local pawn shops. Smash one, move on to the next.
JeezyMcNuggles
Inactive
- Feb 23, 2018
- 14,723
- 20,970
- Disclosures
- I suck, but nobody really notices
Whatever you decide on, it needs some decent high end. Play with a good sized pick, and hit it hard.
Isn't it the phylosophy of Punk that anything is valid?
Then, any bass is fine.
Even no bass. I know one guy that one rehearsing-day he forgot his bass at home and showed on rehearsal without instrument. He just grabbed a microphone and sung the bass lines during rehearsal. The lead singer was a good friend of mine and told me this story. He was very upset, because they were not trying to be punk band, but a blues-hard rock one. But the lesson we all can learn from this story is that when it comes to punk, even no bass is a good punk bass. The only important thing is your attitude. XD
Then, any bass is fine.
Even no bass. I know one guy that one rehearsing-day he forgot his bass at home and showed on rehearsal without instrument. He just grabbed a microphone and sung the bass lines during rehearsal. The lead singer was a good friend of mine and told me this story. He was very upset, because they were not trying to be punk band, but a blues-hard rock one. But the lesson we all can learn from this story is that when it comes to punk, even no bass is a good punk bass. The only important thing is your attitude. XD
I'm kinda old, old enough to remember "real punk" but only when the Orange County bands were ascendant... Punk was, at it's core, about run what ya brung and not worry what was the "right" answer, fashion took over more and more by the time I was paying attention but still.. Best bass for "punk" is really whatever the hell you own.
If you're trying to look punk, the rattiest thing you can gin up.
If you're trying sound like a punk-inspired band, then spend the money on P bass for older stuff or a Musicman for the new school sound.
But if you're honestly punk rock, keeping it to the DIY vibe, then it doesn't matter at all. Plug in, turn on, and make noise.
Any P, J or PJ should do. Hell, anything would work. Punk's not dead, it just deserves to die when it becomes another stale cartoon.
- Nov 30, 2009
- 878
- 195
- Disclosures
- Amateur. Take my advice for its resale value.
If you want a true "punk" tone, its mostly in the hands. Not the bass itself.
For recommendation on $850 bass? Used American Standard P or something with a smooth neck. The key is to have a setup that allows you to play fast, hard, and comfortably.
My current "punk" setup: American Std P parts bass, 1/4lber pickup, nickel round wounds. Amp varies but I always prefer a slightly broken-up tube tone over anything else....
For recommendation on $850 bass? Used American Standard P or something with a smooth neck. The key is to have a setup that allows you to play fast, hard, and comfortably.
My current "punk" setup: American Std P parts bass, 1/4lber pickup, nickel round wounds. Amp varies but I always prefer a slightly broken-up tube tone over anything else....
What kind of punk rock are you doing? This will help with an answer quite a bit.
Everybody will say P bass, which isn't a bad answer. Musicman Sterling basses are worth a good look.
Wow - Unsane's still out there doing their thing? Awesome!
Oh, and yeah, and get a P. They take a beating and keep on ticking.
There's a new Quicksand album?
Their 7" releases were all the best things I'd ever bought back then, but the full length Slip didn't do it for me other than the older songs, and Manic Compressive isn't even on my radar.
devnulljp
Supporting Member
I didn't say *he* was any good but that' the perfect punk bass.
Mind you Sid did epitomize punk sensibilities.
Sid went with a white Precision because that's what Dee Dee Ramone played.
Sid's predecessor in the Pistols, Glen Matlock, played a sunburst P -- no doubt yet another reason he was canned.
I was at a show last weekend and the opener was playing one of those Orange P basses. Sounded really good.
Sergio's tone on Slip is classic, and he's pretty much always played Jazz basses for sure. I've also seen him play Jaquar basses with Quicksand and the Deftones in recent years, but never seen him playa Precision. He's even said he prefers a more trebly tone. Can't argue with that because he's always sounded incredible.
The new record is just them as a three piece. Tom Cappone wasn't part of that recording, and was on the road for a little while for the new record but had some personal issues and left the tour. Can't believe you dont like Slip. never met a Quicksand fan that didn't like that record. It's pretty much what defined that sound. Sure, the Revelation 7" is good, but a bit amateur sounding compared to Slip, which sounded much better and with proper production. It's one of my favorite records ever.
