• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join free Log in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Good seal and finish options from local hardware store or big box?

B

BusyFingers

Guest
Nov 26, 2016
1,909
2,140
#1
I am looking to make some modifications to a headstock, cutting a bit off here or sanding a bit down there.

I want to properly seal and finish it, but want something that is cheap, easy to get, easy to use, and will still leave a nice finish.

I don't have a ventilated area to work in, so it will have to be fume free, too. The wood is a mahogany.

thanks in advance.
 
#2
if you want fume free then lacquer is certainly not your buddy.

glair for pore fill (egg whites) and de-waxed shellac. minor alcohol fumes with the shellac but it dries very fast -keep a window open if you're sensitive. glair is sanded in as a slurry for pore filling in multiple sessions before the finish is applied.

or you can skip the glair and just body and cut multiple times with shellac until you're satisfied.

assuming that you even want to pore fill that is -then if not, de-waxed shellac or wipe-on poly will work. your typical Minwax water based wipe on poly smells a bit like fresh Elmer's glue.

btw, is this a natural mahogany or is it stained?
 
Last edited:
#3
BusyFingers said:
...but want something that is cheap, easy to get, easy to use, and will still leave a nice finish.

I don't have a ventilated area to work in, so it will have to be fume free, too. ...
Click to expand...
That's a pretty tough combination in the world of finishing.

I think the closest you're going to find is Tru-oil. May not be available at a home improvement/hardware store, but you should be able to find it local at a gun shop or a sporting goods store that sells guns. I bought some at Scheels once.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Matt Liebenau
#5
Arie X said:
if you want fume free then lacquer is certainly not your buddy.

glair for pore fill (egg whites) and de-waxed shellac. minor alcohol fumes with the shellac but it dries very fast -keep a window open if you're sensitive. glair is sanded in as a slurry for pore filling in multiple sessions before the finish is applied.

or you can skip the glair and just body and cut multiple times with shellac until you're satisfied.

assuming that you even want to pore fill that is -then if not, de-waxed shellac or wipe-on poly will work. your typical Minwax water based wipe on poly smells a bit like fresh Elmer's glue.

btw, is this a natural mahogany or is it stained?
Click to expand...

It's stained, but I may be cutting off enough to get to bare, untreated wood.
 
#6
TundraMan said:
That's a pretty tough combination in the world of finishing.

I think the closest you're going to find is Tru-oil. May not be available at a home improvement/hardware store, but you should be able to find it local at a gun shop or a sporting goods store that sells guns. I bought some at Scheels once.
Click to expand...

So I won't need to seal it if I use trueoil?
 
#8
Another simple finish I can recommend is Minwax Oil-Enhanced Water-Base Finish. You can get a small can at Home Depot and other fine box stores. It's water base, not flammable, no significant fumes. It can be brushed, wiped, or sprayed on. Dries to the touch in an hour, fully cured overnight. And it has a natural light ambering tint, so it will darken the bare spots a bit probably matching pretty close to the finish that's on there.

No sealer needed. Just put it right on the bare wood, as many coats as you need to build up the finish thickness. It will lay down pretty glossy by itself, but you can level sand it and buff it up to a full gloss if you like.
 
  • Like
Reactions: chinjazz and BusyFingers
#9
Bruce Johnson said:
Another simple finish I can recommend is Minwax Oil-Enhanced Water-Base Finish. You can get a small can at Home Depot and other fine box stores. It's water base, not flammable, no significant fumes. It can be brushed, wiped, or sprayed on. Dries to the touch in an hour, fully cured overnight. And it has a natural light ambering tint, so it will darken the bare spots a bit probably matching pretty close to the finish that's on there.

No sealer needed. Just put it right on the bare wood, as many coats as you need to build up the finish thickness. It will lay down pretty glossy by itself, but you can level sand it and buff it up to a full gloss if you like.
Click to expand...

Thanks for the tip. I may try this.

I've used trueoil before with a so-so result, but I think I should have rubbed it in more than just brush it on with paper towel like this guy suggests.

 
#11
Bruce Johnson said:
Another simple finish I can recommend is Minwax Oil-Enhanced Water-Base Finish. You can get a small can at Home Depot and other fine box stores.
Click to expand...

Do you mean this stuff? It's like $30 bucks for 8 ounces!
minwax-water-based-oilmodified-polyurethane.jpg
 
#12
"i'm modifying my instrument's headstock. i need to spot finish exposed wood. "

let's review:

-must be fume free. -check.
-must properly seal and finish. -define proper?.
-must leave nice finish. -define nice?.
-must be easy to use. -define easy?.
-must be cheap. -define cheap?.
-must be easy to get. -check.
-exposed pores on end grain. -care/don't care?.
-color match necessary? care/don't care?.

since nothing in modern life is that easy, i think we need more info. maybe a picture of the headstock. the suggestions posted in this thread pretty much seem to fit your loosely defined parameters but they still seem to be lacking something. what might that be? :)
 
Last edited:

Latest posts

Top Bottom
Back