• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Has Gretsch been lying to us for over a decade?

Status
Not open for further replies.
I would however really appreciate it being retrofitted with a proper neck pickup. I think I'm more annoyed about all the pickups being bridge models than I am about Humbuckergate. I'm a middle position guy, if I could achieve hum cancelling from a RWRP neck pickup then I'd be perfectly happy.

This is a great point. At a minimum, you should be able to get the Jazz Bass type of noise cancelling when running both pickups at equal levels. It's bad enough to ship singles when they advertise HB, but even worse to wire the singles incorrectly so they don't cancel hum.
 
Honestly, there are plenty of basses with single coils, and more than a few that don't humbuck in the middle position (lookin' at you Rickenbacker), so it's not like it's a deal-breaker when it comes to playability. I also think most people wouldn't care about it either, the issue is and has always been how they are described and advertised. They should just remove the humbucking descriptive content and get on with selling them. :D
 
Folks, I again kindly ask to keep down the bickering. I don't want to muddy the waters here, and we just want to collect as much evidence as possible from as many examples as possible. Eyes on the prize my friends.
I find it a bit amusing that you're asking the people to calm down yet you're the one who created the clickbait title and thumbnail. What else did you expect?
And I don't to want to make this sound wrong. I fully believe that this is a single coil and it looks bad on Gretsch and they need to make it right to the owners. But when you call it a fraud you assume that Gretsch did this intentionally which neither your video nor this thread proved. This could be considered slander.
 
I find it a bit amusing that you're asking the people to calm down yet you're the one who created the clickbait title and thumbnail. What else did you expect?
And I don't to want to make this sound wrong. I fully believe that this is a single coil and it looks bad on Gretsch and they need to make it right to the owners. But when you call it a fraud you assume that Gretsch did this intentionally which neither your video nor this thread proved. This could be considered slander.
He’s coming from the standpoint of not having this thread shut down because of too many flamers. Wants to keep it focused on data based on everyone’s experiences and magnetic paper tests. Very reasonable and straightforward request.
 
As a lawyer, I am amused by all the bad internet lawyering going on here ;)
Aha, a lawyer in the house! Would this disclaimer hold up in court?

screen-shot-2022-04-11-at-8-14-31-pm-png.png


Please don't charge me for this...:D
 
  • Like
Reactions: JLY
Aha, a lawyer in the house! Would this disclaimer hold up in court?

View attachment 4655129

Please don't charge me for this...:D

Rule 1 of being an actual lawyer: Don't give out advice on the internet.

That said, "will this 'hold up'?" isn't a question that can be answered. Depends on the jurisdiction; depends on the claim being asserted; depends on the facts of how it is being applied; depends on the evidence of what happened and what the company knew when.

Thus endeth the lesson.
 
Rule 1 of being an actual lawyer: Don't give out advice on the internet.

That said, "will this 'hold up'?" isn't a question that can be answered. Depends on the jurisdiction; depends on the claim being asserted; depends on the facts of how it is being applied; depends on the evidence of what happened and what the company knew when.

Thus endeth the lesson.
Lots of factors, some or many of which us non-lawyers haven't even considered.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.