• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Hatchet job? (Ending edited and inching toward a postitive)

It appears that the bridge is very narrow. I see that the luthier spread out the strings on the saddles in an attempt to pass over the poles. The spacing between the A and D strings is too far and the placement of the E and G strings puts them too far out on the edge of the fretboard.

The culprit may also be the pickup. Is the spacing between the poles of the new pickup the same as the old one?

The pup was installed at an angle in a poor attempt to reduce the distance between the poles.
You're kidding right? You can't see the pickup is installed wayyyyy off center?
 
  • Like
Reactions: mcnach
I walked into his shop this morning and he was finishing up taking in a repair order from someone. I stood silently and politely with my bass in the gig bag until he finished. The other customer left and as soon as he looked up and noticed me he said, "I was just writing you back. Listen, I will do my best to get you a Fender body. I will do right by you. I will make sure it is already pre-routed." He said he used a template and then something something something. He was very apologetic. I offered to show him the bass to which he said, "no I don't need to see it." Which means he knew he did it. I told him I called Fender and they can't help us and that they said to use Warmoth. He agreed and said he'd order it up today. I told him about the LPB that was there yesterday (according to another poster here) and he asked, "but is it routed for the jazz pickup?" I said no and he said "I'll have them do it." He said he would do it free of charge and apologized profusely. When I got home I went to the Warmoth site to see if that body was still there and it's not, so I am hoping he already placed the order as soon as I left.

Long and the short is, he admitted to his mistake and is willing to fix it free of charge. This made negotiating a lot easier. ;) I'll keep you all updated.

This story may have a happy ending!

Fantastic news! He may not be the best luthier in the world (although even the best can make a mistake), but he seems to be stand up guy.
 
Answer the question. How does it sound? Recordings are blind.
Your are either very insensitive or just trolling. Another possibility is that your standards are so low that you would accept work such as OP had to endure. The probability is very high that the first proposition is true.
 
Last edited:
I would have no qualms whatsoever accepting the Warmoth body especially if they rout the j pickup rout. My most recent bass acquisition has an unlined Fretless maple with vintage tint gloss neck by Warmoth and it's amazing . Maybe you can keep the original body and try one of the larger footprint pickups in the j spot as suggested by others here . Maybe go with a Warmoth neck even and have a pair of cool blues.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MobileHolmes
Just a quick note: Warmouth does not route for Fenders HMV bridge screw pattern last I checked, so unless you plan on affixing it yourself or are just going to be using a standard bridge, definitely do not bring it back to the same guy for that very important job.

Edit: They might have a bridge screw pattern available for the vintage two saddle type which IIRC might the the same as the HMV (minus the through body). Best to consult with Warmouth on which will work best for you.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Gabriel1918
It's clear to me the job was botched.
But it is well understood how it should be fixed. Re-route in the correct location, both east/west and north/south. Then route and fit in a small piece of wood, same as body type. Then fill all seams and refinish, maybe the whole body, at least the front.
Have somebody else do it and charge the original hack.
 
I'd first ask the guy who did the work, or the shop owner what they think about the job that was done. Show them other basses, especially stock Fender ones and point out how off it is. Then ask them in their opinion how they would go about fixing it, if they agree it's actually a bad job.
I think this is a really good approach - take a soft approach and try to get them to agree that it's horrible and something needs be done. I'd go in calmly (a stretch, I know) with what I wanted as recompense firmly in my head.

Good luck.
 
went to a reputable local guitar repairman to see if he could install a j pickup on my American design Experience precision bass. He said he could and he showed me other guitars he’d repaired, built etc. No jazz pup installations but he assured me he could do it. I bought a p/j set and brought it to him. A week and a half later it was done so I picked it up. In the moment, I plugged it in and it sounded good. No ground hum or buzz. Wasn’t thrilled with the rout but it wasn’t enough for me to gasp in horror. I finally got home and took it out. I played for a few minutes then took a closer look only to realize he did a god-awful job lining up the pickup. First I noticed the poles didn’t line up to the strings but thought maybe it was a slight bridge adjustment. Then I noticed that the jazz pickup is dramatically higher than up on the body than the precision pickups. (Not pickup height up and down but position wise into the body). See the pictures below. The blue bass is the one that I am talking about. I put the pencils on there for alignment. The black one was done by another guy when I was working elsewhere and was much closer.

What course of action would you take? It wasn’t cheap and it’s essentially ruined this bass. What do you think? Am I wrong?
 
Glad you noticed. I was being very mindful of that.
Good on you for being cool in this situation. Many others would react differently and make a bad situation worse.
People make mistakes for many different reasons and at least this guy acknowledges this problem - and is willing to replace the body.
I think you should also get to keep the original body.
 

Latest posts