• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Help Munjibunga prove his point about short scales!!!

I think A,C,E are the shorts. That being said I liked the sound of those the best, but this coming from a guy who uses flats on a P (I don't like the sound of a Jazz with rounds). I like some thump in my sound and I think shorts thump really well (can anyone say McCartney?). I'm hoping to get a mustang soon.
 
Hmmm, need more lower notes: E and F to really tell, at least that would help ME :).

I'm guessing A and C are short scales w/ D and E being questionable. B sounds like a good ole 34" jazz to me though.

And, I agree that C sounds P bass-ish to my ears.

Oh, and I used my laptop speakers... so my observations are only as crappy as my speakers LOL.
 
Hmmm, need more lower notes: E and F to really tell, at least that would help ME :).

I'm guessing A and C are short scales w/ D and E being questionable. B sounds like a good ole 34" jazz to me though.

And, I agree that C sounds P bass-ish to my ears.

Oh, and I used my laptop speakers... so my observations are only as crappy as my speakers LOL.

No Jedi mind tricks allowed.

:)
 
I'll say that B & D sounded best to me... also would vote for those as long scale. Hard to say which are short scale. If I were pushed, I'd say C & E are shortscale and A just has dead strings. Personally I'd only be happy with the sound from B & D. Eventually, as we all know, what makes the player and listener happiest should be the final determination, so I'm eagerly awaiting the unveiling of the shortscales and the mustang.
 
I realized that bass C had D'Addarios on and not DRs. Duh, should have noticed the difference colors at the end of the strings. I restrung bass C with DRs to see if it would give any difference. Not much. Perhaps a little more brightness at the top. Please see OP. Sorry for the oops.