• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Help with P Bass Tone

When there is already obviously too much stuff in your chain, suggestions to add ANOTHER stuff is just hilarious.
As other suggested. Start with bass into amp (maybe with compressor, if you really feel urgent to use one), and then try to FIX issues which you would have.

And about "A LOT of bottom end" state, it's 100% valid. It's like guitarists who play endless noodling solo because "which is what I thought is what we go for"
They guy is using a whole 4 pedals.... FOUR. Compressor/EQ/Sansamp/Boost - That most certainly is not "obviously too much stuff". Perhaps more information on how to deploy them may or may not be needed but you guys speak as if he has a 3x5' board filled with pedals
 
The first Precision style bass I had was an old three bolt neck G&L SB1.
I sold it because I thought it was muddy when I played with the band.

In retrospect, my tone controls were all wrong including using my Sansamp BDDI too much and playing through a mid scooped amp and a 4x10 that was also a bit mid shy.

Everyone here seems to be saying the same thing which is what myself and others have found with a Pbass: cut the lows, boost the mids, see how it sounds with the band.

A honky, mid heavy tone soloed often sounds amazing with the band.

I wish I still had that old G&L!
 
  • Like
Reactions: One Way and Artman
It probably has one, but typically they're fixed at anything between 25-40Hz. In order for an HPF to be useful in the kind of situation we have here, we're going to be turning it up to 60-80Hz easily.
I’ve never had mine adjusted to anything higher than 40HZ. In fact, my most usual amp setting features a bump at 40HZ so it would make much sense to set it above 40. Except for upright with a piezo. In that situation it could go to 60.

I don’t know that much, really nothing, about about his situation though. For all we know, it could be the opinion of a singer who’s lost his high frequencies. He might only need to bump some highs.
 
Unless you are playing 1980's blue eyed soul covers. Then your bass should go BIg Bam Boom.
1749654889095.png
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Artman
^^^THIS!

OP: to demonstrate what 96tbird said, go to youtube and listen to some "isolated bass" videos from songs that you are familiar with. You'd be surprised how little "bass" and pronounced "mids" the bass has. It may not sound all that great alone, but in the mix, it's perfect. For example, here is Limelight by Rush isolated bass...



Now here is the exact same bass playing in the mix...


Exactly. My big epiphany was hearing isolated tracks of James Jamerson. I had always thought his sound was the essence of "fat", "round", "warm", etc.
But isolated, he's quite thinner. Plus, dry and maybe not perfectly in tune (poorly maintained bass with ancient, thoroughly dead strings).
 
Using a variable HPF filter along with the amps bass knob, can work very effectively together when tuning to a particular room/mix. I suggest you try out!

Yup, I found that out by chance only a few years ago. Then I started mentioning it to others and found out it was a pretty common technique :D

It allows you to get rid off the lowest lows while reinforcing the 'nice' bottom end, with exact frequency & boost settings depending on the room (and the actual bass EQ control on that specific amp).
 
I was doing a show last night and my lead singer was complaining that my tone was "too fat"; prior to that, I was told by that same singer that my tone was "too muddy"; and also I had someone from the audience say that my tone had "a LOT of bottom end" (which is what I thought is what we go for as bass players)

anyway, i could use some guidance on how to achieve a good P bass that will make 85% of people happy (since its impossible to please everyone)

just for reference, this is my signal chain

2024 Fender Precision Bass (Limited Edition Player 2) ---> shure wireless ---> seymour duncan studio compressor ---> tech 21 vt bass deluxe ---> BOSS GEB-7 Bass Equalizer ---> VC Electronic Spark Boost Pedal ---> Hartke LH1000 Amp Head

any guidance would be most appreciated
Where have you gone, GalardiGrooves?!?

I’m still really interested to hear what kind of music you’re playing!!
 
They guy is using a whole 4 pedals.... FOUR. Compressor/EQ/Sansamp/Boost - That most certainly is not "obviously too much stuff". Perhaps more information on how to deploy them may or may not be needed but you guys speak as if he has a 3x5' board filled with pedals

I agree with you. The demonization of pedals on this forum is outta hand. But it seems obvious the OP needs to learn how everything works in his signal chain.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Zbysek and shoot-r
[Hey guys, i'm new]

I put a 10k Guitar Humbucker in my one, for fun.
Sounds pretty good!
Better than those two Dominoes.

[Not the answer anyone is looking for, but i just wanted to tell someone about it.]
 
I was doing a show last night and my lead singer was complaining that my tone was "too fat"; prior to that, I was told by that same singer that my tone was "too muddy"; and also I had someone from the audience say that my tone had "a LOT of bottom end" (which is what I thought is what we go for as bass players)

anyway, i could use some guidance on how to achieve a good P bass that will make 85% of people happy (since its impossible to please everyone)

just for reference, this is my signal chain

2024 Fender Precision Bass (Limited Edition Player 2) ---> shure wireless ---> seymour duncan studio compressor ---> tech 21 vt bass deluxe ---> BOSS GEB-7 Bass Equalizer ---> VC Electronic Spark Boost Pedal ---> Hartke LH1000 Amp Head

any guidance would be most appreciated

Swap the head with HA3500 and touch with Hi pass filter..... The world change dramatically!!!!