• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

I did a bad thing last night...

What is this..."5 string" you speak of?????

It works like this: They attach a B string below the E - that makes the instrument thick and heavy, but it's more macho. The intonation on the B string is generally off and changes the dynamics of the neck, but you don't have to worry about that too much because the pitch is so low, nobody can tell. The 5 string is mostly for people who don't want to learn first position on a 4.

Flame away...
 
Last edited:
At my age, it's more like...


And the hangovers hurt more than they used to...


LOL, but 'Hookers and Geritol' just doesn't have the same ring to it...

Maybe if you were grinding up the Geritol and snorting them though...


Ultimate Hell for a Bass Player: Forever locked in a room with a drummer that can't keep time:

Invalid Link Removed

No, the Ultimate Hell for a Bass player would also include a guitar player with 7 strings and an octave pedal, and a keys player with a left hand made of lead. And don't forget the drunk singer propping himself up via your headstock.
 
I should mention my first foray into 5 string bass was an abysmal failure. An early 90s Ibanez SR505 that I just couldn't learn to like. The Squier VM Jaguar Bass V Special made me reconsider a 5. I decided on the SX as a good way to go after my 4 string SX turned out so well...

I don't know if I will switch to 5 string fully any time soon but this is a positive step....

I don't want to be a wet blanket here, but as with drummers and double bass pedals, it is not so much that you have a B string, but rather it is considered good form that you use one tastefully.
 
  • Like
Reactions: R Upsomegrub
I don't want to be a wet blanket here, but as with drummers and double bass pedals, it is not so much that you have a B string, but rather it is considered good form that you use one tastefully.

After acquiring a first 5-string last year, it's more useful and musical than I had originally supposed, suffice to say i had always thought many players' use and over-use of the B was gratuitous.

The proper way to think of it (speaking for myself as YMMV), is:

B string/sub-E notes neighborhood... it's a place you visit, not somewhere you live.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Big Hoss
I agree.
I've also seen guys playing 5 strings who don't touch the B all night.
Must be for status purposes.

Probably not fair to say they never touch the B string... their thumb rests on it quite a lot I'd bet :)

And yeah, bassbenji's reply to you might have been more appropos as a reply to my post than yours. I get what he's sayin', the B helps for position playing even without going sub-E. I kinda figured somebody would point out that you can use the B without going low, which is why I added "sub-E" to my post. I do like being able to go down to D or C as the IV of progression in A or G; or being able to play in E flat and go sub-E that way, and so on. But I don't wanna always go there. Just because it goes that low doesn't mean it should always go that low.
 

Latest posts