• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

I don't trust robots yet

Apparently it is their dancing we should fear:



I had an interaction with AI transcription while going through records for work that is so hilariously off I can actually share it. The doctor dictating for sure meant to say "[Client name] is a [#] year old male who blah blah blah..." but what the AI heard was "Teal Waterloo Triangle-Anon is a 119 year old male who..." The records are the opposite of funny but that cracked me up so hard I decided to put down work for the day. It's not like the client's name could even rhyme with "Teal Waterloo Triangle-Anon" and the hyphen is just the confusion on top.



Throughout the mid, to late-90's, I flat out refused to get a mobile phone, because they just turned everyone into loud, annoying A-holes, and texting was annoying for a multitude of reasons...

Instead, I used a pager (which was great as a means of filtering out nuisance calls, and time wasters).

For those that don't know, pagers worked by people calling your number, and a human answer service would take a message, then send it to you in text form.

Several times I received messages that barely made any sense; such as a reference to Truman Capote, which I received as "Through Main Carpet".

So I don't think Artificial Intelligence is any worse than Human Intelligence, in certain conditions.
 
Throughout the mid, to late-90's, I flat out refused to get a mobile phone, because they just turned everyone into loud, annoying A-holes, and texting was annoying for a multitude of reasons...

Instead, I used a pager (which was great as a means of filtering out nuisance calls, and time wasters).

For those that don't know, pagers worked by people calling your number, and a human answer service would take a message, then send it to you in text form.

Several times I received messages that barely made any sense; such as a reference to Truman Capote, which I received as "Through Main Carpet".

So I don't think Artificial Intelligence is any worse than Human Intelligence, in certain conditions.
I both expect the computer to be better and for a human not to make a "Through Main Carpet" level transcription error. Such is the contradiction of expectations.

With medical-specific AI transcription it is pretty much perfect with complex medical terminology. It can discern "pneumothorax" from "hemothrax," and also goes verbatim if they say "PTX" for "pneumothorax," so I think it is mostly the focus/data set.

As far as messing up the person's age, well, that one still eludes me. Throughout the document AI transcribes the client as being three different ages, and I think it was only correct once. Every single page has their date of birth on it. I would think that AI could be trained to recognize language patterns like how a diagnosis might start with "[Patient name] followed by [#] age followed by [gender] followed by [comment/diagnosis]" would be pretty easy. Thought the whole point of an LLM was to do exactly this.

There is good legal AI software though. Thus far it seems like you want it designed or mainly backed by attorneys as opposed to programmers making something useful in the legal field. Right now I feel like the idea is "we can do AI to some degree so what can we jam it into?" versus "I work in this field and think AI could save some time here or there so let's bring in some programmers." YMMV.
 
Throughout the mid, to late-90's, I flat out refused to get a mobile phone, because they just turned everyone into loud, annoying A-holes, and texting was annoying for a multitude of reasons...

Instead, I used a pager (which was great as a means of filtering out nuisance calls, and time wasters).

For those that don't know, pagers worked by people calling your number, and a human answer service would take a message, then send it to you in text form.

Several times I received messages that barely made any sense; such as a reference to Truman Capote, which I received as "Through Main Carpet".

So I don't think Artificial Intelligence is any worse than Human Intelligence, in certain conditions.
That is exactly the problem. AI ( =massive search of our past) IS a reflection of human 'intelligence'.
 
We are not at the point portrayed in the show "Humans" (little slow but good concept) but we are getting there. Why this is going on in a mall is beyond me but hey I'm not a sex robot salesman.

Screenshot_20260511-181329_YouTube.jpg


The future is coming.
 
We are not at the point portrayed in the show "Humans" (little slow but good concept) but we are getting there. Why this is going on in a mall is beyond me but hey I'm not a sex robot salesman.

View attachment 7494708

The future is coming.
Well, he is smiling. Question - - Are you allowed to wear that while riding public transportation?

Better not make any robot jokes around that thing.
 
Well, he is smiling. Question - - Are you allowed to wear that while riding public transportation?

Better not make any robot jokes around that thing.
Is it allowed? I hope not. Does r/publicfreakout lead me to believe it will be on camera within 30min of the product's release? Yes. Without a doubt yes. And they'd probably be sitting next to someone doing something even weirder.
 
Is it allowed? I hope not. Does r/publicfreakout lead me to believe it will be on camera within 30min of the product's release? Yes. Without a doubt yes. And they'd probably be sitting next to someone doing something even weirder.
I've seen what subway Karens do to Google Glass, so can you imagine what they'd do to one of those? And you'd be in VR to experience the whole thing. Ouch!
 
I've seen what subway Karens do to Google Glass, so can you imagine what they'd do to one of those? And you'd be in VR to experience the whole thing. Ouch!
You will need to click on the little 'agree' box before you use it. That way you waive rights to your own data. The company owns it and can do what it wants with it, including handing it over to state or federal law enforcement or selling it to commercial data brokers.