Upon further review, The Player II might be more to my liking. Its quite similar to the Vintera II but does not have the allthread saddles that I don't care for. I am firmly planted on the fence regarding the question of a 2nd P vs something entirely different than I have now though. I am making a point of minimizing overlap between instruments but the flat vs round probably qualifies as a pretty significant difference. Perhaps I could do something different with the pickup as well but not sure that is necessary
I like the idea of a short scale / hollow body type of instrument but I am not sure If I would use it in the real world for the music I do. I guess I'll never know if I don't have one available to use. I think a Starfire maybe? Jack Cassidy perhaps but that is 34"