No, detaining your personal property is not the same action as watching to see if someone shoplifts.
Right - thanks Matt.
To me, one feels so much more drastic than the other.
TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
Join free Log in
Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.
No, detaining your personal property is not the same action as watching to see if someone shoplifts.
But are they keeping the bag or just looking in it, I guess would be the question then. I personally disagree with quarantining it, but if they're just going to look, what's the diff?
It's psychological I guess. Having to open my backpack for them to gawk at what's in it feels like an invasion of my privacy. Again, I know why they do it, I just don't like it.
I agree, I don't like the idea of it either. Plus I find it inconvenient and annoying. But as I said I don't have a need for a bag while shopping so I don't bring one in.
I agree. I also think that refusing to do so is only causing a lot of problems for some poor dude who's only making minimum wage and now has to make a choice of putting his job at risk, or getting into a fight. Both of which actually put his job at risk.
I don't take it personally. If its the store policy and someone doesn't like it I think they should just shop elsewhere.

They respect you a lot.How can the store be respecting a customer when at the same time they have assumed that simply because a person has come in with a bag that they come in to steal.
You would after a few months, when you realize how badly shoplifting cripples your marging and how much customers prefer a safe store with no strange people wandering around all day long, even at the cost of bag inspection.If I had a store I wouldn't treat people like they've come into my store to steal.
The stores only go off of PAST EXPERIENCES. They have seen it too many times. I worked at a store where a woman who was skinny dressed up like a fat woman with a very complicated rig under her huge coat. She stole TELEVISIONS. And this was BEFORE flat screens.
why do you need a bag/backpack going into the store in the first place... :freak:
Why even carry/wear a backpack?
Well a good example would be shopping in the city. We sometimes go to Philly or NYC and go from store to store. In that case, you sorta need a backpack or the wife's massively over-sized hand bag to lug stuff around. In that instance it's hard to leave a bag home. Then you have to check it in, store after store and so on. Kind of gets frustrating.

They respect you a lot.
They assume that you are an intelligent person and as such, are able to realize that people don't always come to stores with the best intentions and that there is no way for shop owners to know yours.
They expect you to understand that leaving your bag at the counter or having it inspected is an efficient way to keep shoplifting down and as such, ultimately allows them to give you a safer buyer experience and lower prices.
It is a lot to ask from a customer, they know it and yet expect people to understand it rather than go whining about it on the Interwebz.You would after a few months, when you realize how badly shoplifting cripples your marging and how much customers prefer a safe store with no strange people wandering around all day long, even at the cost of bag inspection.
Did I call you a name?
That's the problem with tb, can't have a mature conversation. None of us have to agree but calling names is some other bs that seems to work fo some members here.
How would you like it if I called you a jerk for not having enough common sense to know that there is nothing wrong with a person carrying a backpack/bag
For the record what I carrying is a book bag( I made a mistake when I refereed to it as a backpack).
but, it's well known that 98% of all shoplifting occurs outside the store. so i can see why you're upset and feel "violated".That's not the store's problem, now is it?
The replies in this thread bring joyous lulz that you're somehow oppressed because you have to "check in" your bag. But hey, it's not your $$/merchandise getting stolen so what do you care? amirite? iamrite.![]()
people here don't shop with backpacks because we're not weird, i guess...?but, it's well known that 98% of all shoplifting occurs outside the store. so i can see why you're upset and feel "violated".
people here don't shop with backpacks because we're not weird, i guess...?but, it's well known that 98% of all shoplifting occurs outside the store. so i can see why you're upset and feel "violated".