Fascinating thread! Also hilarious how some people are questioning the validity of the advice/experience of the Pro who was asked about career success in his own forum!
Justin - Thanks for showing up in this forum regularly year after year! Interesting to hear that you sometimes have to take lowish-paying gigs to keep things moving forward. One thing I've found among successful people in any field is that while they possess taste, skill, and discernment, they don't feel that they're "better than" the work that needs to be done in the day-to-day.
I know people who are making a living in the music biz, even at this stage in the game. Some as performers, others as producers/studio owners/mixing or mastering engineers, making instruments or electronic gear, teaching, getting music placed in TV or movies -- or a mix of all the above. Besides talent, persistence, attitude, and people skills are what keep these folks in the running. It helps to be young with minimal living expenses and attachments, others I know have supportive spouses or family resources. I supported myself as a jobbing bassist for a few years, then realized I'd rather have a day job than playing music I didn't believe in.
Ari Herstand's site/book is essential for anyone considering a music career these days.
And Tape Op magazine is probably the best, most inspiring resource around for getting insight into how recording artists/producers/engineers have built and sustained their crazy careers.
I don't think anyone's questioning JMJ's validity. But the OP specifically mentioned that he's considering trying to make a career out of creating original music instead of teaching, which he's doing now. That's going to be a tough road, especially with family obligations.
