• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Is there a "wrong" way??

This.

You can say Flea made a career out of playing the bass “wrong,” but I’ve heard the guy has had several surgeries to help address issues in his hands/arms from years of poor form/technique. I’m certainly not perfect in my approach either, but there is typically a better, if not “correct,” way to do most things.

I recently discussed my buddy who started needing to wear ear plugs any time he was in public due to getting tinnitus at about 26 years of age. These types of injuries are not fun. I don’t 100% agree with a stranger calling out someone’s technique in public and at random, but I can understand it if there was some genuine concern on that individual’s part.

Yes, exactly this!

Sure, music is art, art is subjective, and you can totally play with only your pinky held upside down while slamming your right forearm into the body of the instrument to produce vibrations. You can probably even navigate some classic punk rock tunes this way. But that does not mean it's the most efficient or effective way to play.

Your body wasn't designed for this to begin with, and abusing your body can have long term consequences. Plus, the bass sounds much better (I know, this is subjective) when played with some generally agreed upon techniques. You don't HAVE to fret right behind the fret, but it sounds better, cleaner, and is easier to do. If you are choosing to move your finger a half inch back you aren't some brilliant rebel sticking it to the man, you're just making it hard on yourself and making your music sound lousy.

As for fingerings, there are best practices for those, too. Someone might play the whole line on a single string when crossing strings is way easier and sounds cleaner as a result.

I once sat down with Victor Wooten and showed him my progress in learning a very technical and complex piece of his, and he said "That's cool, nobody has ever shown me they learned that before. But, you are making it hard on yourself, if you change these notes to open strings and finger it this way it's going to be easier to play and the open notes will ring longer, which is what I was going for."

He didn't tell me I was wrong but he did show me his way and explain his reasoning. In my opinion, those are the marks of a great teacher. Oh, and that night he played the song at the gig at my request, which was nice to see our little lesson come together in real time on the stage. :)
 
Before the GC Police Police jump all over the guy who we didn't hear from, perhaps he was offering suggestions about a better way to play it. Sometimes even if the note is right - the feel or connecting to the next phrase can suffer if you play it differently. The OP is admittedly a beginner. Perhaps the guy was trying to help and his tact sucks.
 
Yes, exactly this!

Sure, music is art, art is subjective, and you can totally play with only your pinky held upside down while slamming your right forearm into the body of the instrument to produce vibrations. You can probably even navigate some classic punk rock tunes this way. But that does not mean it's the most efficient or effective way to play.

Your body wasn't designed for this to begin with, and abusing your body can have long term consequences. Plus, the bass sounds much better (I know, this is subjective) when played with some generally agreed upon techniques. You don't HAVE to fret right behind the fret, but it sounds better, cleaner, and is easier to do. If you are choosing to move your finger a half inch back you aren't some brilliant rebel sticking it to the man, you're just making it hard on yourself and making your music sound lousy.

As for fingerings, there are best practices for those, too. Someone might play the whole line on a single string when crossing strings is way easier and sounds cleaner as a result.

I once sat down with Victor Wooten and showed him my progress in learning a very technical and complex piece of his, and he said "That's cool, nobody has ever shown me they learned that before. But, you are making it hard on yourself, if you change these notes to open strings and finger it this way it's going to be easier to play and the open notes will ring longer, which is what I was going for."

He didn't tell me I was wrong but he did show me his way and explain his reasoning. In my opinion, those are the marks of a great teacher. Oh, and that night he played the song at the gig at my request, which was nice to see our little lesson come together in real time on the stage. :)

Critique
 
Are you having to jump all over the neck or are you playing in one position? There is definitely a right way and wrong way. If you are hitting all the right notes but are not utilizing economy of motion there is a problem.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Groove Doctor
Yeah I dunno man. if someone did that to me when I was also a beginner I'd probably be horribly embarrassed and feel bad about my playing. Intent doesn't really matter, don't bother strangers with unsolicited advice. Do you really want to be the guy who discourages someone from playing an instrument in public?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Benji bassman
Reminds me of the time my friend and I were trying out guitars at GC. Trying out some chugs and taps, and some geezer leans over and tries to tell us "guitars aren't meant to be played like that." :rollno:

Can't imagine having an ego that made giving unsolicited "advice" an imperative.
As a geezer, I say what I want at this point in my life. If the little tweezers are that sensitive oh well.
 
Are you having to jump all over the neck or are you playing in one position? There is definitely a right way and wrong way. If you are hitting all the right notes but are not utilizing economy of motion there is a problem.

Except that there are differences in the way that things sound. I tend to gravitate toward the middle of the neck because the notes there have a fuller low end. Also there aren't two ways to play any given thing. There are frequently a ton of ways, and sometimes you'd rather move your fretting hand around than your plucking hand, etc, and there are differences by genre. If you're playing country, you're gonna look like a goof if you're all over the neck. If you're playing rock, that's pretty much how it's done much of the time, from McCartney onwards.
 
Reminds me of the time my friend and I were trying out guitars at GC. Trying out some chugs and taps, and some geezer leans over and tries to tell us "guitars aren't meant to be played like that." :rollno:

Can't imagine having an ego that made giving unsolicited "advice" an imperative.
426148_v1.jpeg
 
Before the GC Police Police jump all over the guy who we didn't hear from, perhaps he was offering suggestions about a better way to play it. Sometimes even if the note is right - the feel or connecting to the next phrase can suffer if you play it differently. The OP is admittedly a beginner. Perhaps the guy was trying to help and his tact sucks.

Are you having to jump all over the neck or are you playing in one position? There is definitely a right way and wrong way. If you are hitting all the right notes but are not utilizing economy of motion there is a problem.

I guess we’ll never know until the OP posts a video of him playing it.

Or maybe the dude wasn’t a jerk, but was a savant and it was hurting his ears to hear ‘the wrong way’. I’m a bit like that… but at least I know when to shut my pie hole.
 
There can be a better way, more efficient usually, but if you're playing the right notes in the correct timing - all is good. I guess there are times when you want to play in a certain register to get a tone closer to the way it was recorded, but at that point are you playing the same bass, the same amp, the same strings, etc.
 
This reminds me of the threads on this site claiming that knowing how to read music is a waste of time.

Trust me when I say that, when you know your positions, your fingerings, when you know how to plan your next shift to be as efficient as possible, that you will be a better bass player.
 
  • Like
Reactions: aprod
I’m going to be brutally honest here, but back when I tried playing guitar, I played by ear using the same approach I do with bass. The number of times I was told I played something the wrong way despite the notes being correct along with tempo and rhythm drove me up the wall. To the point it put me off of wanting to play guitar seriously. Some day I’d like to get back into it but my experiences have left a gross taste in my mouth that still lasts unfortunately (metaphorically speaking of course).

It seems as though bass players can get away with this much more easily. It could be because people pay less attention to bass players, but it’s one of the things I love about bass. I play things how I want and let my creative freedom flourish. It’s just a more satisfying experience to discover different ways to play something. “Correct” notes or techniques be damned. By the way, the way my ways of learning a song came to be was simply because of the incredible shortage of accurate bass tabs for almost songs I’ve ever wanted to learn (death metal and thrash), so I’ve had no choice but to train my ear and play songs how I hear them played, not how I think it should look as it’s played.