Krist is and was a great bassist for what he IS PLAYING. His basslines were right in your face in the mix and really drove Nirvana IMO. So many people say this player or that one sucks etc. Thats not cool and its not true. Does Krist suck? No. Is he Victor Wooten or James Jamerson, NO! BUT HE DOESNT HAVE TO BE! Thats the point.
You play what fits the music, his lines fit Nirvana's sound. Simple as that. Just cause he isnt jamming on his bass like Jaco doesnt mean he sucks. He played with Nirvana and they sold about 50 million records. Thats a lot more than 99.9% of any of us will ever do or achieve. I just dont understand why someone can tear down another musician like they do.
I played drums for four years and still play them. Now John Bonham was a GREAT drummer, but he is no Buddy Rich is he? Was he? NO! But can anyone here honestly see Buddy playing with Led Zepplin? Of course not, but they were both incredible drummers, just DIFFERENT. Is anyone else seeing my point here?
I see your point very well. You play your genre of music to the best of your ability. Novoselic played in /grunge/punk/alt. rock and played the hell out of it. He isn't Jamerson but like you said can anyone imagine the soulful James Jamerson playing Smells Like Teen Spirit or Come as you are?