No more than $1500, shipped. Last listed at $1950 and probably sold with an offer of $1750. There is absolutely nothing to indicate a reason to pay MORE than that last listed or sell price. Quite the opposite.
Was the case shi**ed up in shipping as well? The thing travelled in a case (in a box) and those headstock and finish dings are unlikely in-case travel damage IMHO. And, on teh long shot that's true they may have then negotiated a refund arouns the delivered damage. Again, unlikely in my mind but just playing thing out.
Maybe contact the prior owner/seller to verify the story
Bassman