Let me start by saying I really liked the neopunch P pickup on its own. It definitely is a unique thing with tons of growl, bark, and punch. It was a little too hot for me and lacked brightness, though rolling back volume cleaned it up enough. The J was just completely lacking to me and sounded nothing like my Fender J. It was overly compressed and had no dynamics or sparkle. And solo it had buzz and hum. Fully blended there was a big volume drop I couldn’t compensate for with pickup height, and the blended tone was just a dark honk to my ears. There was no brightness, and no dynamics. It compressed too much when you dig in. So it just didn’t fit the tone I had in my head of a PJ.
I bought this bass having only heard clips online, so I went into this knowing I might swap pickups if I liked everything else. Basically I like how Scott Devine’s Fbass sounds and when I listened to clips of other Aguilar equipped PJs I felt that was more what I wanted. I wanted that classic P and bridge J sounds and I wanted some of that more modern PJ sparkle and spank in the blended tone. Enough builders are using them that I figured it was a low risk mod.
My original plan was to just replace the J with a humcanceling Fralin or Nordstrand and keep the neopunch. But that would have require a very overwound J and I realized that what I was seeking required a more wound traditional J. So I decided on a full swap knowing I might miss the neopunch.
I think the Aguilar set really delivered. They are a very balanced set and dead quiet. That was the first thing my tech told me when I picked it up. The P is pure chocolate classic P. Great mids and maybe a little underwound compared to the fender custom 60 in my Am Std P. The J has almost all the sparkle of my Fender, no noise, and I can hear it blending in with the P more than I did the Lakland set. It barks and has punch. Fully blended they scoop out nicely and sparkle. It sounds like a PJ as I hoped.
So you’ll notice I didn’t say better. Tone preferences are so personal. By the time I made the swap I was having reservations about doing it. So I’ll say it’s definitely different. The better part, for me, is very even balance between the pickups, no noise, dynamic range, and spot on traditional tones.
Sorry for the long post! Here are some pics because she’s so purty. Lol
View attachment 4218936 View attachment 4218935