• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Let’s have a poll about picks!

What’s your absolute favourite pick for playing?

  • Dunlop tortex

  • Dunlop gel

  • Gravity razer

  • Gravity classic

  • Piglet graphite

  • Dunlop Jazz III

  • Dunlop stubby

  • Dunlop big stubby

  • Dava grip

  • Graphtech

  • Dunlop Jazz III graphite

  • Dunlop nylon

  • Timber tones

  • Dunlop delrin

  • Carbon fibre

  • Bone/horn

  • Fender celluloid tort

  • Titanium/steel

  • Glass

  • Other


Results are only viewable after voting.
Thanks Pablo,
You got the brand right! Many thanks. I’ll dig into it. Just needed a place to start because it’s such a big ocean. Thx bud.

C
Definitely planet waves. I think it's the Surepick

Invalid Link Removed

They are unavailable at the major retailers so might not be produced any longer :nailbiting:

Looks there are still online seller's that have them. Black seems to be the heavy ones.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ChrisWright
Started using this one recently....I kinda like it.

preview.jpg
 
I've mostly used Dunlop Jazz picks since I found out they came in an "XL" size (which is just normal pick size instead of those tiny little things). Great balance of attack and fatness, and great control + texture. I've tried tons of picks and they really seem to be the best for my overall uses. I occasionally use a thinner Herco (forget which one, but its actually their version of a "Heavy") for more aggressive/twangy playing.
 
I don't play bass with picks very often, and haven't really found a pick that I like for the times I do. For guitar, I swear by the Dunlop Jazz III (Only red, and not the ones with the grip stuff on them), but I don't like those on bass
 
  • Like
Reactions: sunbeast
I don't play bass with picks very often, and haven't really found a pick that I like for the times I do. For guitar, I swear by the Dunlop Jazz III (Only red, and not the ones with the grip stuff on them), but I don't like those on bass
Have you tried the XL version of the red Jazz pick? They are my FAVE all-around bass pick! The normal sized ones are too small for me with bass (I use the XL size for guitar too though)
 
how so? thanks.
There aren't many 'bass picks' out there, as most bass picks are just normal picks in a heavier gauge, or stiffer material (Tortex). Actual bass picks are typically made of felt, which softens up the sound, but still gives you the advantages of a pick. Only problem with felt is that it's no match for a bass string long-term, as felt isn't terribly durable.

The Wedgie, which is a rubber bass pick, gives a similar type sound to felt, but offers a more durable material. If I remember correctly, they had different different thicknesses, and different rubber materials as well, so you could get them to fit your tastes. Another thing that made them cool was that the pick was concave where the thumb goes, making them quite comfortable to hold.

Lastly, the reason "it's not my thing" is because I'm sort of against playing my bass with a pick, strictly for control and feel. I find I play better finger-style than I ever could with a pick.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jhengsman and JRA
The Wedgie, which is a rubber bass pick, gives a similar type sound to felt, but offers a more durable.....
got it --- thanks for responding! ;)

the reason "it's not my thing" is because I'm sort of against playing my bass with a pick, strictly for control and feel. I find I play better finger-style than I ever could with a pick.
right: i'm lousy (poor technique) with a pick and have relied on fingerstyle from the beginning. i've used a pick in the studio before, but that's not like a gig! that said: i keep thinking that if i found a pick i could actually 'hang on to' i might be tempted to use one once in a while for that "click" effect (on fretless).
 
got it --- thanks for responding! ;)


right: i'm lousy (poor technique) with a pick and have relied on fingerstyle from the beginning. i've used a pick in the studio before, but that's not like a gig! that said: i keep thinking that if i found a pick i could actually 'hang on to' i might be tempted to use one once in a while for that "click" effect (on fretless).
Get a thumb pick, you don't really have to hang on to it all it just slips on your thumb.
 
  • Like
Reactions: akrachanko
I choose the pick that sounds the best with which ever bass I'm using and the strings that are on it.
With Laklands and Sunbeams I'm back to using a Fender celluloid.
With Fenders and Sunbeams it's Tortex or soemtimes a California clear with SS rounds.
All heavy or extra heavy; the type of plastic really does make a difference in the tone for anyone who hasn't experimented.
 
All heavy or extra heavy; the type of plastic really does make a difference in the tone for anyone who hasn't experimented.
Yeah when I realized this I went down a HUGE rabbit-hole testing different picks. Both the pliability and material matter for playability and tone. I love the aggressive brightness from lighter picks but find them super hard to control, but too thick and you lose the attack. Most shredder picks guitarists love have too much attack for bass IMO, though the Dunlop Jazz picks are a great balance and are obviously well loved by guitarists- for me they are a great all-around pick for any instrument (in the XL size for my big fingers of course!).
 
I voted the Dava Grip picks since they've been one of my absolute favs since I found them.

But recently, I've started playing with a "Big Stubby" and like it a lot. It gives off a fatter sound to my ears. Also, because it's a smaller pick, it forces me to play more so with the tips of my thumb/forefinger as opposed to the meat of the side of my forefinger. My hands are relatively large, so it takes a little more concentration to maintain grip, but it forces me control the pick a little better since I'm gripping it at the tips of my fingers (if that makes sense).
 
Definitely planet waves. I think it's the Surepick

Invalid Link Removed

They are unavailable at the major retailers so might not be produced any longer :nailbiting:

Looks there are still online seller's that have them. Black seems to be the heavy ones.
Hi Again - I’ve looked around a lot (including the link you sent / thank you) but can’t seem to find these online. Any chance you can shoot a link where they actually have on hand/stock to sell? I truly appreciate it.
I see plenty of places that list them but when you click on the link you find that they don’t really have them. Thanks for your help.