• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Lobster Roll?

Lobster Roll?

  • Hot with butter

    Votes: 11 39.3%
  • Cold with mayonnaise

    Votes: 13 46.4%
  • not neccesary

    Votes: 2 7.1%
  • with carrots?

    Votes: 2 7.1%

  • Total voters
    28
whelp, I'm dumb. Hard not to chew that.
yes they are glorified crawdads. I had some in China that were among the best things I ever ate though. It was 18 years ago and I still remember like it was yesterday.
Sorry to be so long-winded, and for hijacking, but it flowed out of my fingers at light speed.

not to worry, I'm okay with this thread veering into various food discussions.

case in point:
Where's your favorite pizza spot I vote Pizza House on Howard Ave?

And to pull it back on topic where's some good seafood joints?

I will cheat and name 2 - the one I grew up with, a great example of NY style, is Glenville Pizza (which is on Glenville Rd in Glenville.) You can get a slice in either pepperoni or cheese, a Sicilian slice, or a salad pizza, which they claim to have invented, which is basically a dressed lettuce salad on top of a pizza dough and is much better than it sounds. They also do full pies either regular or Sicilian with toppings, Garlic and sausage being one of our favorites. They also make calzones, which have a really thin dough unlike any other I've ever had anywhere. They only take cash, at least as of the last time I was there in 2010.

the other,closer to where i live now, is Camille's Wood Fired Pizza in Tolland. They sell only smaller whole pies, and take a more Italian approach, with a few specialty pies with unusual ingredients like bacon and eggs or red onion, goat cheese, honey and pistachios. It's a funky little dining room with a good beer selection as well.

Those are just my top 2, I've been to dozens of other great spots. Even the bad ones are decent compared to some other pizza deprived regions.
 
yes they are glorified crawdads. I had some in China that were among the best things I ever ate though. It was 18 years ago and I still remember like it was yesterday.

We call those crawdads 'round here, about as much meat as a prawn but with the shell of a lobster. Worth it when they're fresh and well seasoned but to much work otherwise.

Wait, are they different animals, or just different names for the same thing? I thought prawns WERE shrimp.

In this case, I suppose it's better to say I've had prawns face, shell and all, not shrimp. Still tasty though.
 
Wait, are they different animals, or just different names for the same thing? I thought prawns WERE shrimp.

In this case, I suppose it's better to say I've had prawns face, shell and all, not shrimp. Still tasty though.
Crawdads, Crawfish, Crayfish, Langostiens, are all the same animal, prawns are big shrimp and much easier to eat, I used it to illustrate size. Crawdads taste similar to lobster and are sometimes called poormans lobster.
 
  • Like
Reactions: pie_man_25
Ah, but at least you can get a real crab cake in MD. If anyone else has spotted the real thing outside the Chesapeake Bay area, please let me know!

BTW, I will be traveling through your fair state tomorrow, and plan to get off I95 somewhere near Havre du Grace and have some crab. Any suggestions would be welcome.
Lee's Landing Dock Bar:
Welcome
 
  • Like
Reactions: Radio
I grew up in Maine, and there are only two ways to eat lobster that I recognize:

#1: Boiled alive with a side of hot butter (clarified).
#2: In a lobster roll, which is a crappy hot dog roll topped with a cold lobster salad (chunks of lobster meat leftover from #1, mixed with a bit of mayonnaise and kept in the refrigerator).

There is no other way.

A fellow Mainiac, I was wondering in Maine I was told always growing up you HAD to boil the lobster alive because when they die a bacteria spreads. So putting them in the boiling water alive prevents it.

I see on chef shows they will cut the lobsters head in half before putting it in water. I guess it's big in high end restaraunts but every time I see that on a cooking show I just feel like they are doing it wrong and going to get someone sick. Where you told this about lobster too?

Edit: not lobster it is lobstah
 
nothing like playing a crab feed and part of the deal is the all-you-can-eat crab dinner.
Messy!! and no matter how well you wash your hands (usually with the flimsiest paper towels in the world) still feels like yer getting crab guts all over your strings.
Solution = have the nice ladies throw two or three in a plastic bag and deal when you get home!

I live on the South Oregon coast, so have this down.
Cracking crab is a lot of work and messy. I don't order whole crab dinner out. Buy it at the dock - best eaten in the home setting!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Will_White
I grew up in Maine, and there are only two ways to eat lobster that I recognize:

#1: Boiled alive with a side of hot butter (clarified).
#2: In a lobster roll, which is a crappy hot dog roll topped with a cold lobster salad (chunks of lobster meat leftover from #1, mixed with a bit of mayonnaise and kept in the refrigerator).

There is no other way.

The only lobster roll I've ever had came on nice brioche bread, with a heavy dose of butter, and was then crisped up on the flattop. So good! Crappy hot dog roll?
 

Attachments

  • image.jpeg
    image.jpeg
    96.1 KB · Views: 25
How are there any left overs from #1 in order to make #2 ???
:laugh:

when you do "two fers" 2-3 times a week, you get burned out on Lobster pretty quickly. I don't think I could eat Lobster any more ... unless it was right off the boat and cheap (because it had only one claw, thus headed to the cannery)
 
The only lobster roll I've ever had came on nice brioche bread, with a heavy dose of butter, and was then crisped up on the flattop. So good! Crappy hot dog roll?

Yep, like so:

johnny_ads_lobsterroll.jpg


Which is from the local dive hot dog stand we mostly shunned and ignored during my youth in Connecticut. I grew up within sight of lobster pot floats, but it was never really considered anything all that special in my family. Several years ago I was visiting for the first time in many years and asked a childhood friend where to eat. That was the last place I expected to be pointed to, but it was killer.