I've seen a lot worse than that totally restored by a good luthier. In theory he should be able to make good on it -- i.e. touch it up in a way that's scarcely visible to the eye.
Last edited:
Enjoy the benefits of a premium membership!
Upgrade Account
-
TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
Join free Log in
Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.
Luthier screwed up my P bass
- Thread starter funkmaster p
- Start date
-
- Tags
- luthier precision bass
Glad you were able to come to an agreement over the battery compartment. Of course, I would have had a little fun with him like "You sure you can do that without @#$%ing it up?!!!"
It sounds to me like you guys are fairly close and even if you weren't I personally would still be ok with it.
Nobody ever sees the back of a bass. And a bass is just a tool. Period. You're the only one who will ever know.
There isn't that many decent luthiers out there, sounds like you found one.
Nobody ever sees the back of a bass. And a bass is just a tool. Period. You're the only one who will ever know.
There isn't that many decent luthiers out there, sounds like you found one.
Had something similar happen. Except in my case the damage was on the front. Extremely disappointing. Had to sell the bass. Couldn't look at it.
plenty of fender p bass bodies on ebay usually ...............................
Tough luck on the accident for both of you. My thought is that if the bass is a good bass, I would be reluctant to replace the body. You don't know what it will be like till it is done. If it were me, I would look into plugging / filling the hole and spot finishing it as good as possible. Resale will be affected, but not really that much. It's not like it is a vintage '61 or anything like that. But having the bass back that you are familiar with is worth much more to me.
If you look at some of the stuff Dan Erlewine(sp) does on his Stew-Mac videos, this seems like it might be a pretty straight forward repair. Might be worth posting the pic in the luthier forum for advice.
If you look at some of the stuff Dan Erlewine(sp) does on his Stew-Mac videos, this seems like it might be a pretty straight forward repair. Might be worth posting the pic in the luthier forum for advice.
It's a beautiful looking sunburst ... I would have him turn the hole in the back into a battery box and be done with it. Functionally, it's a WAY better configuration than having to de-install/re-install the pickguard whenever it's time to change the battery. You could probably even go with a two battery/18 volt system if your EMG pickups support it.
That's what you get for wanting a PJ Bass. Kidding...
At least he's willing to eat it. Have those drinks and then call Fender for a new American body.
Then, let him finish for FREE if he wants to salvage his reputation.
A few years ago now, I commissioned a luthier for a custom spec Jazz Bass. Well, he managed to have it painted the wrong color and mounted a DEFECTIVE Hipshot bridge on the body. The factory admitted to a run of bridges that had the mounting holes drilled in the wrong place, so all the saddles had to sit at a diagonal in order to line up properly. So, this guy drills the 5 mounting holes in the wrong place. Not only did he not want to do anything about it, like give me a new body, the prick wanted me to pay for a new set of strings as I brought the bass back with strings removed to show him the problem.
Sorry for venting but I've been wanting to tell this story. PM me and I'll tell you who he is.
Man, that's horrible! You don't have to tell me who the guy is, but what became of that bass?
I'm thinking a battery box is not likely due to control cavity on the other side. The box is going to take up space out of that cavity, and your luthier's luck will have it that where a pot or jack is located.
Sounds like the old rule of "measure thrice and drill once" was not used. I'd be looking to add more luthier business cards to my rolodex after this.
Sounds like the old rule of "measure thrice and drill once" was not used. I'd be looking to add more luthier business cards to my rolodex after this.
It's not like the body is irreplaceable and the dude is making good on it. Don't sweat it.
Well, he mounted a vintage threaded saddle which managed to work out as there is so much adjustability with the threaded barrels, so I grudgingly took it but couldn't get the bad taste out of my mouth and didn't want to advertise his product on stage so, after a few months, I sold it for an $800 LOSS. Never again.
Repair the damage and move on. Its on the back. Dont worry about it.
If I still had a mind I could tell you a thing or two, sonny boy!
What are you fretting about? That'll buff right out! 
Last edited:
I would love to have a guy like this work on my instruments. Have him repair or replace the damaged body and carry on.
Luthier screwed up my P bass
I find the use of the word 'Luthier' in the title a little peculiar, given the subject.
I'd want a new body if that happened.
I find the use of the word 'Luthier' in the title a little peculiar, given the subject.
I'd want a new body if that happened.
I recently drilled a P-Bass body for a bridge ground wire, and did the very same thing. I was not very happy with myself !
