Yeah, I caved and added that part. I usually read stuff with all the YMMV, IME, IMO included, even if it isn't, and assume most people do the same. I'm trying to start a new trend where everyone always knows that's what I mean, unless I add NIABAI, "No If's, And's or But's About It!"
LOL! I totally hear you. I just thought it was funny.
Thing is, I really do know guys who can play very dynamically and even bounce back and forth between slap/finger without a compressor online. It does take more finesse, it is difficult to do well, but it's totally do-able, and allows you to keep yer signal chain just that much simpler, which I always like. Even if I can't hear a diff, it's just nice to cut connections.
Obviously, however, like you're saying, there are certain dynamic things you can ONLY do if you're pushing an amp hard, and/or really beating the crap out of the strings at times... Geddy does this, and I tend to do it as well on my GL sig J. On the old passive J bass, there's just something really cool that happens with the growl when you abuse it.

However, I also find my style changes based on the bass. I have the action pretty low on my Skjold, MTD, and Celinder in particular. There's just something about the elex in those basses that I can get everything I need without radically changing right-hand technique like that. So with my J, I like to have a compressor hooked up, but with the others, I prefer not to.
Anyway, of course I can alway go on and on, and of course YMMV (sorry, couldn't resist

), but hopefully that's a reasonable example.
