Hi all. Does anyone have any experience of the Mesa Subway Bass DI versus any of the Sansamp DI boxes?
Yes, I have a BDDI v1, VT DI, and used to have both deluxe versions and a VT Bass. I searched for that certain tone I had in my head and was convinced the Tech 21 stuff would deliver it. No doubt, they are good boxes and some players love them. As for me, I've moved away from them because at this point I can really say they are generally not for me.
The Mesa blows them all out of the water. To my ears the BDDI is the best of the lot, it's earned its reputation for sure. But the Mesa is way more versatile. I have not been able to get a BDDI tone out of the Mesa but, that's not what it's for. If you want the BDDI tone, use a BDDI!
I still have the BDDI and have a VT DI and will likely hang on to them. But, they are not on either of my boards. My main rig is a D-800 with a Mesa Diesel 4x10 from the 90's. I have a board that has a couple of pedals. The chain looks like this: MXR Bass Compressor -> MXR Carbon Copy -> MXR Analog Chorus -> HOF Reverb -> Sub 'n Up -> Darkglass VMT -> Mesa Flux Five -> Ampeg SCR-DI
To my ears the combination of the SCR-DI into the D-800 is money! I use this setup for my main band which is a Casting Crowns tribute band. What I have in this setup is a ton of options. I strive for a warm tube like sound that is just under when the amp starts to overdrive. I have that in spades with this setup. I can use any of the the three dirt boxes alone or in combination to color a slightly distorted tone. The three options are: scrambler, Flux Five, and VMT. I love the sound of low gain distortion and can get that very easily by tweaking a couple of knobs.
I also play at Church and use IEMs with a small board and no amp. I have the following signal chain:
MXR Bass Compressor -> Corona Corus -> Subway DI.
When I had to decide on a preamp to use in the latter application, I could have chosen one of the Tech 21 boxes but, that really was never a consideration. I went straight for the Subway DI when we wen to IEMs. For this situation, I play a 5 string Fender Jazz with Ernie Ball Cobalt Flats. The strings are almost 2 years old and the Mesa is silky smooth with this setup.
So the point is that I can go from hard driving rock, to ballads and anthems, to mellow music all with the Mesa subway preamp. I don't really need much more than that!
I find that the Tech 21 boxes, while good, are not great. I do like the BDDI but, it's kind of a one trick pony. If you are looking for a scooped sound, it's a winner. Even the V2 with the mid control is still a BDDI at its core. If you like the sound of it then it's a winner but, I find you won't get much variety out of any of them really.
Now, the VT related boxes, I find them flexible to a certain degree but, the Mesa and Ampeg preamps are much more musical. I've played them side by side and find the Tech 21 stuff just does not measure up to either the Ampeg or Mesa. Comparing the VT boxes to the SCR-DI... no comparison. The latter has the "Ampeg tone" in spades. The VT while good I would not say nails the Ampeg tone.
With all this said, it really is subjective. I'm sure there are players out there who would come to a completely differnt conclusion. Hope this helps. If you have a follow up question, I'm happy to weigh in with my opinion. BTW, yes I gigged with all of these pieces and gave them the benefit of time. This has been a 2+ year endeavor to try to get to where I wanted to be from a tone perspective. I'm finally there, and unfortunately spent a little coin in the process.