Well, monsterthompson helped me understand that the fx loop sends a different signal level than expected, so I suppose I'll hold off on trying that out. However I would love to just rant about my experience with these Darkglass pedals and see if anyone has any comments or advice.
The bass I'm using is a Dingwall ABZ5 (passive or active, doesn't seem to make a huge difference either way).
In short:
I used a B7k Ultra pedal for a while and it was cool, but I don't feel I've reached the potential I have with the gear I'm using. I tried to reduce the size of my pedal board, so I ditched the Markbass Little Mark III head and the B7k Ultra, and now I have that same circuit inside my amp head with the Microtubes 500 (which also has the Vintage Deluxe if you'd rather).
The B7k seems like such a drastic mid scoop to me. Works a little better when I detune a lot, when playing Periphery songs for fun and use a ton of gain.
For my party band playing, I'm realizing the Vintage circuit is better for me. Acts more like my sansamp but with more high mids. It gets clanky when I want it to and even then I'm not even at 50% on drive and tone and such.
The X I'm using is the smallest version without the EQ sliders. FYI, I'm using a spectracomp before it and that specific toneprint is squishing the low end really hard just like the other X pedal. The best sounds from that pedal so far have been
-lowish gain
-big mids boost
-almost all of the low frequencies present, and very little high end content being distorted. (Both knobs basically cranked clockwise)
I can get a lot of cool sounds in my bedroom but I'm learning that like all pedals, it sounds so incredibly different at high volume and in a live mix. Once I'm live and loud, everything goes awry. The X sounds sandy. Jacob Umansky gets such a bright, clanky, sparkly sound with it. I'm not sure what I'm missing. The B7k sounds super scooped and the presence gets lost...at times, even the pitch gets lost. I think I still need to play around with the Vintage Deluxe because it sounds like that's the one I like best but, idk.
I understand that the crossover idea makes sense. Nice clean lows and super gritty high end. However, doesn't that leave out all the meat in the mids? Sometimes this process makes it sound like a flubby bass and a gritty/sandy guitar running in parallel. I'm looking for one solid sound, not two parallel signals that are going simultaneously. In a live mix, that high end blends in with the other instruments and all that's left is that flubby low end, right? Does that kind of make sense?
I learned recently that I've spent all my life cutting mids, but it seems that in reality: loud live mix means more mids are necessary. This is why my favorite control on the other DG pedals is still the BLEND knob. I love the clean sound from my bass still, so it's cool to simply adjust how much of the wet signal you want to hear. I resented the blend knob on the sansamp. If you went full dry, there was no high end...just sludge. That's not a blend knob, Tech 21. My first DG pedal? Turned the BLEND all the way down and heard crystal clear dry signal. YES thank you.
Not really looking for an answer, (I know I never really even identified what sound I'm looking for) just wanted to speak out loud to people that get it