• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Mohini Dey - 2019 NAMM

I actually like MonoNeon. Way more melodical in his approach to playing. He does some amazing stuff. And he grooves!

Exactly.

The fact that he'd be mentioned with her shows how much merit the so called musicians tag has :D If you can't hear a blatant difference between these two...

Okay. Who's next, Thundercat?
:D
 
I'd much rather listen to Tal play. I'd much rather listen to Rhonda Smith play. I'd much rather listen to Michelle N'Degeocello play. Melody and groove capture my attention. Mohini is really good. No denying that. She's doing what makes her happy. I'm all for that. My personal taste is danceable, funky and melodic. I mentioned Uriah Duffy. He was a NAMM staple for a few years. His videos I will watch.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Eidolon0274
In my case, absolutely. It's funny that someone would think that not caring for something requires not understanding it.

Speed doesn't blow me away.
I think this happens quite often and I wouldn't blame anyone for falling into this - especially when they feel quite strongly about something.
As to speed; it's a tool that doesn't require any more than physical exercise and time put in. There's no Art in it as such for me, or music.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: IamGroot
Trips me out how so called “musicians” can’t stand high caliber proficiency.

She’s a monster player with chops for days and her low notes tone is fantastic.

Appreciate the compliment, but I'm just a bassist.

I can stand high caliber proficiency for hours if I like the style of music being played by the proficient one. Proficiency in itself is not the entertaining factor. The style of music is a major factor in determining how long I can watch & how much I enjoy a display of proficiency.

Example: this guy is also proficient in what he does, but I didn't make it all the way to 6:15.....

 
I think this happens quite often and I wouldn't blame anyone for falling into this - especially when they feel quite strongly about something.
As to speed; it's a tool that doesn't require any more than physical exercise and time put in. There's no Art in it as such for me, or music.

Speed can be impressive for people who struggle trying to attain it. It's nice to have it in your toolkit and even better when you figure out how and when to deploy it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Phat Nick