I showed this song list to my girlfriend who is also a musician, and we both think it is fairly schizophrenic. I'm all for a diverse setlist, but is this an R&B band? Is it a country rock band, is it a rock band? I think trying to please everyone is probably not going to please anyone
Well, I don't know what kind of band it is, either. Some of the song choices, like heavy keyboard or horn songs, are questionable but it may be interesting to see how they cover them. And the one Tyler Childress song was kinda random. Does that mean they're open to new country or does one of them just like THAT song? And I don't know if this initial list is indicative of the kinds of songs they will want to do going forward or just a list of songs that they already know and would be easy (for them!) as a (more of less) audition set.I agree on the setist being all over the place...i tend to think of sets like that as filler which doesn't do it for me, but I think it helps bands that I play in if the songs sit together well.
And your average gig attendee quite likes to know what sort of band you are...a bit of everything doesn't help them get their head around the band...plus bookers are keen to know what you do so they can market it.
They like to vary their offerings so they don't want too many 80's band...but there are always too many 80's bands anyway.