Hmmmm.....
Feeling serious G.A.S. since I have heard of the new Sire P/J - Basses. Swamp Ash in white with all maple neck.... Yummi!!!
I'll give Thomann Germany a call next week, asking for a date for shipping - and if there is an idea what happenes in case of being a P-neck - lover.
I would have no problem, if there would be a factory made neck to swap later, maybe the bass is great with the J - neck, lets see - and then decide.
I think, I know why so many bassplayers recommendet Sire to use a Jazz Bass style neck.... The Sire company sold a shitload of the V7 - modell, stock with Jazz Bass style neck, and so the fans of Sire did recommend the neck they know and love already. There was not a single real Precision - guy interested in Sire - Basses, until they told us they are going to built a P or P/J - Bass. This was the moment, the brand came into focus of people that like the more chunky P-Bas - necks better - as I do.
I have some MusicMan -Basses, one StingRay 4 and two 5-bangers, one StingRay Classic 5, two Bongo 5, one BigAl 5, there is an original 1964 Precision Bass and more, and I have to say, that I prefer the Precision-, Ray- and Bongo-necks before the slimmer neck of the BigAl. But I love the look and the sound of the BigAl. So I am not saying "I can't play it because it is too slim", I like more flesh in my hands, but am able to play slimmer necks. And so are you. Does the slimmer / fatter neck change the sound of the bass? Lets see, nobody knows - until someone has the chance to check it out.
So, if the whole package is right, like sound and playability is OK, why not trying the slimmer neck? Unless there is an option to get a chunkier one later. OK, I would prefer having it stock with the fatter neck, but it comes out like I have to get me another neck lets see, if I can find a single body on EBay, making this my next project. As I sayd before, if I have to change the necks. Lets check it out first.