First off, I didn't say Kitna was on par with Palmer. I said he played well. I think everyone here would agree he DID play well, considering the circumstance.gamera said:To say that Kitna is on par with Palmer is just ludicrus. Plus imagine Rothlisberger goes down. Do you really think Batch is as good? Kitna did ok in the first half, after that give me a break. How well did the Eagles do with their backup this year?
Some backups suck, some backups kick ass. Using the McNabb example is poor unless you look at BOTH sides of the coin....
Let's see.... How well did Tom Brady play when Drew Bledsoe went out injured, hmmmm? How well did Ben Roethlisberger play when Maddox went down with an injury, hmmmmm?? I'll answer for you. Well enough to take the starting job away from the other. There are countless other examples of this also, but I feel two makes my point nicely.
)