Yeah, I'm not so worried about the Wings Post Lidstrom. I realize they aren't as good of a team. But the best team doesn't win the Stanley Cup. If any one thinks they do just look at the Kings record this season. The Wings healthy have about as good of a chance as anyone. Right now in the west Chicago seems to be the class of the conference, but that won't mean much in the second season.
One question, has goalie become the hardest position to fill in the sport and the one least worth making a large investment in with the cap?
Think about this, with the exception of Martin Brodeur what goalie in this league has put together a great run for 3-5 years? The reality is while you need a superior goalie capable of making a great playoff run to win the cup, last years hero, tends to be this years nightmare? Luongo? Giguere?
Throw Thomas in there.
Goalie does seem to be the hardest position to fill. Even the B's Chiarelli who has been on a good run recently with Thomas, Rask and its early but Khodobin; admited that he was the one that went out got Manny Fernandez for 2 years at 4.5M per. It reminds me of closers in baseball.
That said, I think you have to make the investment - no risk, no reward. Maybe try to limit the years, but good goaltending gives you a chance every night and that is worth a premium price. Like A-rod's salary, it is not the per year that kills you, it is all the years of premium pay after the production has peaked.