• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Non technical yet excellent bassists

^^^
I just remembered, (I'm an REM fan) they hired JPJ as orchestral arranger on their great "Automatic For The People" and Mike Mills was pretty much in awe of him.

The Diamanda Galas dig on the others, isn't really without merit. Jason Bonham, who'd come from outside in to the rehearsal in 2007 reunion, had this to say:

Jason Bonham Talks Tensions Between Jimmy Page and John Paul Jones

Quote verbatim:

"Baited into a discussion of why Zep multi-instrumentalist Invalid Link Removed has been treated like a second-class citizen by Invalid Link Removed and Invalid Link Removed, Bonham refrained from offering much comment, but he was more forthcoming when Monahan opined that Jones brought more to the table, musically speaking, than many realize — and he went on to open a window into the decades of tension simmering below the surface when the band reunited for its O2 Arena show in 2007.

“He’s a well-educated — there’s a certain bracket, and I don’t know what the American equivalent is … he conducts, he can chart, orchestrate, arrange, produce, you know, hands down,” Bonham said of Jones. “So much so that there was a time when we were rehearsing with those guys, and we were doing a part, and Jimmy — Mr. Page — was counting it as guitar cycles. He’d do it and say, ‘That’s 16 guitar cycles. That’s right, isn’t it, John?’ and John goes, ‘Whatever.’ He goes, ‘No, no — John, we’re right, aren’t we?’ and John goes, ‘We’ve never been right. What’s the point of continuing now? You do it your way, and I’ll do it the correct way!'”

OUCH!! :blackeye:

So no, JPJ shouldn't be mentioned in this thread at all, it's totally OT. Or John Baldwin as his real name is. JPJ is a stage name taken from an old maritime admiral, or military officer, and an aricraft carrier, or war vessel of some sorts. Beats me why he took that name...

EDIT: It's Diamanda Galas, not Amanda...sorry, my bad.
 
Last edited:
The Diamanda Galas dig on the others, isn't really without merit. Jason Bonham, who'd come from outside in to the rehearsal in 2007 reunion, had this to say:

Jason Bonham Talks Tensions Between Jimmy Page and John Paul Jones

Quote verbatim:

"Baited into a discussion of why Zep multi-instrumentalist Invalid Link Removed has been treated like a second-class citizen by Invalid Link Removed and Invalid Link Removed, Bonham refrained from offering much comment, but he was more forthcoming when Monahan opined that Jones brought more to the table, musically speaking, than many realize — and he went on to open a window into the decades of tension simmering below the surface when the band reunited for its O2 Arena show in 2007.

“He’s a well-educated — there’s a certain bracket, and I don’t know what the American equivalent is … he conducts, he can chart, orchestrate, arrange, produce, you know, hands down,” Bonham said of Jones. “So much so that there was a time when we were rehearsing with those guys, and we were doing a part, and Jimmy — Mr. Page — was counting it as guitar cycles. He’d do it and say, ‘That’s 16 guitar cycles. That’s right, isn’t it, John?’ and John goes, ‘Whatever.’ He goes, ‘No, no — John, we’re right, aren’t we?’ and John goes, ‘We’ve never been right. What’s the point of continuing now? You do it your way, and I’ll do it the correct way!'”

OUCH!! :blackeye:

So no, JPJ shouldn't be mentioned in this thread at all, it's totally OT. Or John Baldwin as his real name is. JPJ is a stage name taken from an old maritime admiral, or military officer, and an aricraft carrier, or war vessel of some sorts. Beats me why he took that name...

EDIT: It's Diamanda Galas, not Amanda...sorry, my bad.

Interesting anecdote.
I agree JPJ doesn't fit the bill for this thread. A few other names don't either. I'm thinking especially of Jack Cassady, who was also mentioned earlier.
Actually, if I had to make a category in which to fit both JPJ and Cassady, it would be "Bassists who were the most accomplished musician in their own band." And I'd add Chris Squire in there.
 
Oh, and how could we even forget the immortal PETE STEELE ?! Of Type O'Negative. He's dead though, but you'll never know with this guy...;)

peter-steel-reuters-photo.jpg