• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Not tolerated as a musician

Yacht Rock: Steely Dan, Michael McDonald, Fleetwood Mac, Ambrosia, Atlanta Rhythm Section, Phil Collins, Doobie Brothers, Christopher Cross, Hall and Oates, The Eagles, Genesis, Little River Band, Todd Rundgren, Jefferson Starship.

The key word is smooth.
Almost 100% stuff I don't like that much. Hmmmm....
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jeff Roller
We go by the general rule that whoever leads the song singing gets to decide what kind of backing the rest do. Our group plays mostly schlocky crap introduced by the primary singer. Mediocrity is ok for him and because it is it's difficult to get the drummer to do anything different. However when songs are introduced and sung by either myself or the keyboard player we tell them what we want and expect.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jeff Roller
Getting back to OP's post, I understood the complaint to be that the drummer would play the same rock 4/4 pattern regardless of a song's style. I don't think OP was asking the drummer to play in 5/4 or 7/8 or some such. There are plenty of 4-beat patterns that are not 4-on-the-floor (or "Boom-Thwack-Boom-Thwack-Boom-Thwack-Boom-Thwack-CRASH!").

Getting back to the OP's post, he specifically told you, not once but twice, that he doesn't want answers.

Now YOU quit derailing our silent ponderance (as requested by OP, mind you) of the efficacy of an amateur bassist trying to rearrange perfectly rendered rock and/or smart (b)assists (copyright) giving grammar/vocabulary lessons to said amateur bassist who possibly doesn't even comprehend ninth grade English vocabulary yet worries about musicians who don't push themselves.
 
Last edited:
Yacht Rock: Steely Dan, Michael McDonald, Fleetwood Mac, Ambrosia, Atlanta Rhythm Section, Phil Collins, Doobie Brothers, Christopher Cross, Hall and Oates, The Eagles, Genesis, Little River Band, Todd Rundgren, Jefferson Starship.

The key word is smooth.

A friend of mine is in a "yacht rock" band. Dumbest name for a genre comprised of the (almost) worst music on radio. Every time I think of playing this music I think of where I'm going have to hang my testicles, or just leave them at home.

If I wanted smooth, I'd go to the smooth jazz side. At least it's got some mojo, a little.
 
Getting back to the OP's post, he specifically told you, not once but twice, that he doesn't want answers.

Now YOU quit derailing our silent ponderance (as requested by OP, mind you) of the efficacy of an amateur bassist trying to rearrange perfectly rendered rock and/or smart (b)assists (copyright) giving grammar/vocabulary lessons to said amateur bassist who possibly doesn't even comprehend ninth grade English vocabulary yet worries about musicians who don't push themselves.
Yes, Miss Manners. :-)
 
I was in a situation like that once, people were talented but inflexible, but they booked a lot, yachta yachta yachta, I quit.

I like lively songs, and those yacht rock slow ballasts never did it for me; the female singer annoyed me... 'fore the gigs, she'd be acting ridiculous, and then aft 'er words about my attitude really bothered me. But at least you can sometimes get a little sail trim. The guy whose band it was, Lee Ward, was a good guy though, and the drummer in that band and I really anchored the whole thing.

In your situation I think yatchta quit.
 
Last edited:
A friend of mine is in a "yacht rock" band. Dumbest name for a genre comprised of the (almost) worst music on radio. Every time I think of playing this music I think of where I'm going have to hang my testicles, or just leave them at home.

If I wanted smooth, I'd go to the smooth jazz side. At least it's got some mojo, a little.
Sorry you hate awesome music.
 
Yacht Rock: Steely Dan, Michael McDonald, Fleetwood Mac, Ambrosia, Atlanta Rhythm Section, Phil Collins, Doobie Brothers, Christopher Cross, Hall and Oates, The Eagles, Genesis, Little River Band, Todd Rundgren, Jefferson Starship.

The key word is smooth.

not The Eagles ;P



PS...just saw Ambrosia about a month ago...they absolutely tore the roof off the place
 
"Money can't buy you happiness -but it can buy you a yacht to pull up next to it"
LOL
Classic
david-lee-roth-jumpin-for-the-devil.jpg