• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Ok, BIG AMP lovers, which one would you choose...

Which BIG amp

  • Ampeg SVT(any variation)

    Votes: 114 40.6%
  • Mesa Strategy Eight:88

    Votes: 31 11.0%
  • Mesa Prodigy Four:88

    Votes: 10 3.6%
  • Aguilar DB751

    Votes: 27 9.6%
  • Fender Super Bassman

    Votes: 42 14.9%
  • Orange AD200B

    Votes: 16 5.7%
  • Ashdown CTM-300

    Votes: 11 3.9%
  • A boutique builder(Reeves, Verellen, Electric, etc)

    Votes: 30 10.7%

  • Total voters
    281
IMG_0643.JPG

Why? Because it is the one.
 
Either the all tube 300W SVT (no explanation needed IMO) -or- the Fender Super Bassman. Same 300W of classic 12AX7 + 6550 goodness - but 20 lbs. lighter than the SVT.

Truth is, all those monster all-tube amps sound great. If they have a "heart of glass" they get my vote. I cut my teeth and grew up with that sound. So to my ears, that will always be what a bass amp should sound like.
 
I'm a big fan of the Fender Super Bassman (and Sunn 300T, same thing). There's just a certain "something" about it. A roundness that, while it can be attained from almost any of the others mentioned, seems to just ooze out of the Bassman at all settings.

That said, I'd rather have the 3.5lb Mesa head. Even if it only gets you 80% of that sweetness (and let's be real, it goes well beyond that) it's doing it at a tiny fraction of the weight and can fit in a large gigbag pocket.

Solid state and hybrids have proven their place, especially in today's builds. To say otherwise is typically just posturing.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Sparkl
My votes go to the Mesa Strategy, then maybe an SVT-4 Pro, then an SVT classic or Fender Bassman, then the Prodigy, then the DB-751. The Bassman is much more versitile than one would expect, but I think Mesa has an edge on tone and reliability. The Strategy is just a sick amp. The Ampeg and Mesa stuff can all achieve similar tones so it comes down to power and features, and there I think the Strategy wins.
 
Depends on what style you play and what you want to achieve. I own a Verellen Meatsmoke and it is hands down the best sounding amplifier I have ever played through for the style of music I play. To one person the sound of an SVT or Orange will be what they want, but it may not be another person's sound.

Ask yourself how do you want it to sound. Do you want grindy saturated overdrive, slight bark, smooth and fat, or a jack of all trades type of amp? It is quite an investment in money and weight, but unless I don't have another bamdmate to help me cary it or my arms fall off I'm never giving up that tone.

I used to not believe the hype surrounding tube amps until I lived with one for a while. There really is something unquantifiable about the way those things sound. Good luck.
 
I've owned 4 tube heads. First was the Fender Bassman 300 Pro (looked like the Sunn Model), Traynor YBA200, Traynor YBA300 and now the Ampeg SVT-VR

Verdict;
Bassman in that design was super awkward to carry but was a workhorse.
Traynor YBA-200 - it was awesome, should NOT have got rid of that thing, weighed like nothing and sounded good.
Traynor YBA-300 - doesn't sound as good as the 200, could be because of the 6L6 tubes rather than KT88's.
SVT VR - has that mid heavy tone. takes pedals awesome. Weighs the equivalent of a small elephant. So much so my back is kinda messed up and I'm only 25!
 
If I HAD to choose between anything above, I chose the Mesa Eight88. What an amazing amp!! I actually have an Electric Power Unit and I love that amp. It’s prefect for what I do and for my band. However, now that I have had it for a few years, if I could do it over again, I just might have sprung for the Mesa Eight88. It’s got all the options like a DI, more EQ, all those bells and whistles in a KT88 powered beast. What more would you ever need?!


#SVTkiller ;)
 
I'm a big fan of the Fender Super Bassman (and Sunn 300T, same thing). There's just a certain "something" about it. A roundness that, while it can be attained from almost any of the others mentioned, seems to just ooze out of the Bassman at all settings.

That said, I'd rather have the 3.5lb Mesa head. Even if it only gets you 80% of that sweetness (and let's be real, it goes well beyond that) it's doing it at a tiny fraction of the weight and can fit in a large gigbag pocket.

Solid state and hybrids have proven their place, especially in today's builds. To say otherwise is typically just posturing.
The fender super bassman is a different amp from the sunn 300t. You're thinking of the fender 300 pro.. and yeah .. it's the best amp made!
 
  • Like
Reactions: rodl2005