I think you and I are heading towards the same sweet spot. P bass with flats, high mass bridge, and 0.1uF tone. Mine is a 50's P with 760FLs and a Gotoh 201. And she can cover some ground.
I actually don't like heavier mass bridges. I swapped out the BAII that my Highway 1 had and put on a vintage style Highway One P bridge (what they used before the "upgrade"). The high mass added a subtle amount of sustain that I think took away some of the qualities of the P that I was looking for.
Got it. I went for an Orange Drop .1uF and a 250K pot. Not a bad experiment for under $6.![]()
You'll notice a huge difference. Even with stock pickups, just putting in a new cap dramatically changes the tone. When I removed the Greasebucket tone circuit in mine even before I replaced the pickups, the .1uf cap made a huge change.