Oh yeah, I've learned to not argue with those type of books, they have obviously used other sources besides their ears
. Looks like George picked up some tips from Paul.
Enjoy the benefits of a premium membership!
Upgrade Account
-
TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
Join free Log in
Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.
Paul McCartney and his Basses
- Thread starter JD Supernatural
- Start date
Oh yeah, I've learned to not argue with those type of books, they have obviously used other sources besides their ears
. Looks like George picked up some tips from Paul.
In the film Let It Be, George is (was) often seen playing a Fender Bass VI while Paul played guitar or piano. It’s been a long while since I’ve seen the film — since anybody has seen the film, for that matter — but Maxwell’s Silver Hammer and Two of Us stand out in my memory as songs that I believe featured George on the Bass VI.Oh yeah, I've learned to not argue with those type of books, they have obviously used other sources besides their ears
I have it on DVD but can't remember either but I'm sure the book must be accurate.
Although George is clearly playing the Fender Bass VI in the Let It Be film, Paul was in the habit of later overdubbing parts others played on HIS songs. The sound and style on the finished Abbey Road recording sounds like him to me So IMHO, it's Paul.
Bad example, IMO. Lennon mangled The Long and Winding Road. I've read that Spector laid on the strings and choirs specifically to cover up his atrocious bass work, but I could hear it at age 14 in 1970. I can't think of any Lennon bass lines that were proficiently played, though Helter Skelter somehow works in the mix.
I play in a band that does a lot of Beatles. We even used to do the whole tribute thing. I learned that line note for note just to irritate the BL. (He's a huge John Lennon fan, and I'm an a$$4o1#)
Paul used to record his bass parts last, so I believe George filling in on bass during certain rehearsals was no uncommon. I can’t wait to see Let It Be when it’s re-released as well - it’s been decades since I’ve seen it.
BTW, I believe George played his part on “Two of Us” on his Rosewood Tele.
I’m pretty sure that all of the Beatles,Ringo included, could play multiple instruments. I saw Paul playing a Mandolin a while back. George Harrison was a player and collector of Ukulele’s.
What ever was needed I’m 100% sure that any one of the Beatles would have gotten the job done.
What ever was needed I’m 100% sure that any one of the Beatles would have gotten the job done.
I'm not saying Lennon wasn't a competent musician. But he was known to hate having to play bass, and between his disinterest and heroin use, his limited bass work on Let It Be was particularly poor.
Lennon is playing the Bass VI in Let It Be, not George. I don't recall seeing George on bass anywhere in the movie, while John plays it on "Let It Be," "The Long and Winding Road" and jams like "Dig It."
If you want to hear Lennon attempt to play sax, pay attention to the squealing in the later sections of "Helter Skelter." It's him on sax, while the other noise is Mal Evans on trombone.
- Nov 27, 2003
- 2,017
- 5,417
- 50
- Disclosures
- Rogue luthier employed at Knooren Handcrafted bass guitars
Well you guys, guess what popped up on Youtube today?
John did play bass on "Let It Be" in the movie but Paul overdubbed the bass on the released recording at the behest of George Martin
.
- Steve
Last edited:
I thought the bass lines he played on Let It Be and The Long And Winding Road had to be redubbed by Paul, owing to John's mistakes (lack of interest?)
Paul dubbed in the bass on Let It Be (the song), but for some reason not Winding Road, the finished production of which he famously hated.
