• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Paul McCartney Dings His Hofner

I mean, ultimately, it's all speculation, right? The joke about Sting's relic'd P was just that - a joke.

The more serious point is, why risk losing or irreparably damaging your favourite instrument when 99.99% or your audience will never pay that much attention to what you're playing as long as you're playing their favourite songs?
Life is that way. You play what you want, whether for tone, feel, nostalgia, history, bandmates/audience expectations, all the above. Even after Mr. John Hall's statement, "4002? We didn't make too many of them. They're rare as hen's teeth,) added a zero to the digits value of my bass, (yes, 4002, not "1" or "3") I continued to play it as my main gig bass, alternating with my fanned fret P-style bass during recuperation after injuries, until I needed a 5-string. It still comes out for concerts here and there with my old band when we have a reunion and other smaller gigs here and there.
 
I mean, ultimately, it's all speculation, right? The joke about Sting's relic'd P was just that - a joke.

The more serious point is, why risk losing or irreparably damaging your favourite instrument when 99.99% or your audience will never pay that much attention to what you're playing as long as you're playing their favourite songs?

Because you risk dinging it if you play it at home too, so way not take it to the gig and enjoy playing it while you still can?
 
  • Like
Reactions: DJ Bebop
I'm also willing to bet that's not the Hofner he played many years ago. That one is worth mega bucks and is likely in a safe somewhere waiting to be auctioned off by his heirs.

it most certainly is the "real one"

there were two basses early on, the pickups were different. one had a middle and neck, the other a bridge and neck.

the middle/neck (there are model numbers but i don't know them) was stolen pretty early on, and has never been found.

the other was used on tons of beatles stuff (though not as many recordings as folks think - he used the rick a lot), and that is indeed the bass he still uses today. same one from the rooftop, same one from live on ed sullivan, and so on.

there's a great book with detailed photos called "beatle gear" that goes over all of this - and quite a bit more. a fun read if your into this stuff. it's mostsly awesome pictures of original beatle gear.
 
Paul's Hofner would go for way more than $500,000. The last time I remember it was insured for over a million. That was a long time ago. In today's world I bet it would be a way heavier price.

also this...

i imagine if this bass was to one day be auctioned, it would be the most expensive musical instrument purchase... ever?

really depends on which uber-weathly collector is into it.

not that i ever expect it to be auctioned anyway.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 12BitSlab

Attachments

  • upload_2022-8-11_12-52-58.png
    upload_2022-8-11_12-52-58.png
    88.5 KB · Views: 29
  • Like
Reactions: DJ Bebop