• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

PJ Basses

I’ve got a few basses in my Arsenal but the one thing that’s missing is; wait for it, wait for it…. A P Bass!

So… I don’t really want a modern P so if I get anything it will be a PJ. I’m not a big fan of production brands but I could be swayed, the closest I have to a production instrument is a KSD ProtoJ. Looking forward to your suggestions.

For what it's worth, I have a MIA PJ. I't a great bass and have had it for 18 years now.
 
9C2825D0-DD93-4B7E-B2D7-6AB1F7E6563B.jpeg
After experimenting with a few different PJ models this is the one I decided to keep and use.
The dual coil Nordstrom bridge pickup really balances the sound. It’s passive and the controls are Volume - Pan - Tone. 1.75” nut and right about 8.5 lbs.
 
Are we defining "PJ" as literally any bass in the world with a split coil pickup in the neck position and a j-style single coil pickup in the bridge position? Or a Fender Precision bass with an added J pickup? Or a Fender Jazz bass with an added P pickup? What if it's an Ibanez sound gear? Didn't Alembic make a bass with both of the aforementioned pickups? I've seen headless Steinberger copies with P and J pickups. Is this a PJ too?
 
  • Like
Reactions: BOOG
Are we defining "PJ" as literally any bass in the world with a split coil pickup in the neck position and a j-style single coil pickup in the bridge position? Or a Fender Precision bass with an added J pickup? Or a Fender Jazz bass with an added P pickup? What if it's an Ibanez sound gear? Didn't Alembic make a bass with both of the aforementioned pickups? I've seen headless Steinberger copies with P and J pickups. Is this a PJ too?
Yes, As you’ve probably seen many brands have been listed. Others have also suggested a PH, a humbucker in lieu of the jazz so quite a bit here for consumption.
 
Build a mutt. That way you get the neck profile and body style you want. The biggest problem P/J basses have is the incompatibility of a single coil and a humbucker mixed. The output near the bridge is lower than near the neck due to the narrower string vibration. Putting a weaker pickup there intensifies the effect. If a P/J had the P pickup near the bridge and the J near the end of the board like an EB- 0 it might mitigate the problem. This can be avoided by replacing the single coil Jazz pickup with a humbucker. Either that stacked type of the side by side style will work. Lowering the P and raising the J will help even them out. I like the DiMarzio Model Js with the adjustable poles and the cream colored covers. They are side by side coils and sound like a P bass only more focused. They work well in a P/J application. Hope this helps.
 
I was going to suggest that you look at these, I had one for a few years but then got deeper into the upright bass realm and sold it (regrettably). Great sounding bass that was super-comfortable to play. When it comes to bass guitar, I am mostly a P=bass guy and the Reverend was the only PJ over the years that I was able to bond with. They recently put out a 25 yr anniversary model that looked great, not sure if there are any out there that are available.
Relook at that pic, it is a 25 year anniversary.
;0)
 
  • Like
Reactions: 2cooltoolz
Well, I went the DIY approach. The 4 string is an American Vintage Hot Rod body with an American Standard neck. The 5 is an American Standard body with an American Professional (1) neck.

My PJs reduced.jpg


They both have stacked Vol/Vol pots with a single tone control and 3 way J/B/P switching, to isolate the pickups.
The 4 has a Seymour SPB-1 "50s" voiced Precision pickup with a Fender Super 55 split coil Jazz.
The 5 has a Nordstrand NP5F Precision 5 Pickup and an NJ5FS split coil Jazz Bridge Pickup.

For all you pj players…
Do you play both pickups primarily or one or the other?
When do you split them and why?

I run the P pickups on each 95 percent of the time and use the jazz pickups isolated occasionally. Even soloed, the Jazz PUs sound more like a set of Js blended then a solo single coil to my ears. I almost never run them combined with the Ps.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Mark Ellis
Build a mutt. That way you get the neck profile and body style you want. The biggest problem P/J basses have is the incompatibility of a single coil and a humbucker mixed. The output near the bridge is lower than near the neck due to the narrower string vibration. Putting a weaker pickup there intensifies the effect. If a P/J had the P pickup near the bridge and the J near the end of the board like an EB- 0 it might mitigate the problem. This can be avoided by replacing the single coil Jazz pickup with a humbucker. Either that stacked type of the side by side style will work. Lowering the P and raising the J will help even them out. I like the DiMarzio Model Js with the adjustable poles and the cream colored covers. They are side by side coils and sound like a P bass only more focused. They work well in a P/J application. Hope this helps.
I may keep an eye out to see if I can find a vintage p & j pickup to drop into some body and build sone sort of Franken pj.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jamro217
Well, I went the DIY approach. The 4 string is an American Vintage Hot Rod body with an American Standard neck. The 5 is an American Standard body with an American Professional (1) neck.

View attachment 4753009

They both have stacked Vol/Vol pots with a single tone control and 3 way J/B/P switching, to isolate the pickups.
The 4 has a Seymour SPB-1 "50s" voiced Precision pickup with a Fender Super 55 split coil Jazz.
The 5 has a Nordstrand NP5F Precision 5 Pickup and an NJ5FS split coil Jazz Bridge Pickup.



I run the P pickups on each 95 percent of the time and use the jazz pickups isolated occasionally. Even soloed, the Jazz PUs sound more like a set of Js blended then a solo single coil to my ears. I almost never run them combined with the Ps.
You know. Now that I think about it I may start off on that route. I may try to pickup a vintage j & p pickup and drop them in a Sadowsky MetroExpress for now and see where that goes…
 
I may keep an eye out to see if I can find a vintage p & j pickup to drop into some body and build sone sort of Franken pj.
The beauty of mutt building is that control every aspect of them, from the cost and the quality of the materials used to the timeline to any special mods you want. You become your own custom shop. You can fill the pickup cavities and cut new ones in different location to get just the blend you want (think '60's versus '70's J pickup spacing). Best to you.
 
  • Like
Reactions: johnnynitro
Well, I went the DIY approach. The 4 string is an American Vintage Hot Rod body with an American Standard neck. The 5 is an American Standard body with an American Professional (1) neck.

View attachment 4753009

They both have stacked Vol/Vol pots with a single tone control and 3 way J/B/P switching, to isolate the pickups.
The 4 has a Seymour SPB-1 "50s" voiced Precision pickup with a Fender Super 55 split coil Jazz.
The 5 has a Nordstrand NP5F Precision 5 Pickup and an NJ5FS split coil Jazz Bridge Pickup.



I run the P pickups on each 95 percent of the time and use the jazz pickups isolated occasionally. Even soloed, the Jazz PUs sound more like a set of Js blended then a solo single coil to my ears. I almost never run them combined with the Ps.
You almost had me excited. I was like when did Fender start making a PJ5?! You routed the J pickup yourself? It doesn't look like you damaged the finish at all.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 2cooltoolz
070A4AC3-4D59-4D46-A672-8B34C3A896BC.jpeg
My go-to basses are Spector Euros. Both are reverse P/Js. My Euro 6LT has the reverse P and the J pickup in soapbar shells.


Over the years, I’ve owned a couple of Precision style basses with PJ setups. They were excellent for recording projects and for live playing. For my tone goals, a PJ setup is my favorite.
 
Last edited:
I’ve got a few basses in my Arsenal but the one thing that’s missing is; wait for it, wait for it…. A P Bass!

So… I don’t really want a modern P so if I get anything it will be a PJ. I’m not a big fan of production brands but I could be swayed, the closest I have to a production instrument is a KSD ProtoJ. Looking forward to your suggestions.


If you already have a jazz, keep it and use it.
View attachment 4752432

This is what I have; Great Bass a Tad underrated here on TB


That thing is amazing looking. No snobbery here. I have owned PJ basses in the past and you can produce some good tones for all styles. This thing looks badass ....