• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

PJ Club

Not sure if I posted it in here yet, but here's my modded Jag bass. Its been a labor of love.
C76E72C7-2B6E-45F0-8B69-C8930A2ED5FA.jpg
 

I've always been intrigued by pickups with the smaller number of large pole pieces. That, combined with my love of a good P/J configuration, leaves me with a bunch of questions. For example, what's your take on their overall sonic "palette" and what do they have to offer that sets them apart from the more standardized pickups?
 
I've always been intrigued by pickups with the smaller number of large pole pieces. That, combined with my love of a good P/J configuration, leaves me with a bunch of questions. For example, what's your take on their overall sonic "palette" and what do they have to offer that sets them apart from the more standardized pickups?

Malak...I believe the general consensus is that they create a stronger and wider magnetic field...so in theory you get more output...or some such thing...
 
  • Like
Reactions: Malak the Mad
Hey, Snake! It's been a while! :)

Malak...I believe the general consensus is that they create a stronger and wider magnetic field...so in theory you get more output...or some such thing...

Greater output, and by extension greater volume, makes sense, but I'm curious as to what that does to the texture of the sound. Is it smoother or grittier? Does it add more zing? Would it lead to a harsher sound, much like I got when I tried out an SD Quarter Pounder P-pup in my first parts-bass? (In that particular case, it was too harsh, so much so that it completely overpowered a strong Super 55 J-pup. Ultimately, I had to go with something a bit more mellow.)

I know, I know…I'm asking using some pretty subjective, non-scientific terms, but I'm cool with it if I get some equally non-scientific feedback. ;)
 
Hey, Snake! It's been a while! :)



Greater output, and by extension greater volume, makes sense, but I'm curious as to what that does to the texture of the sound. Is it smoother or grittier? Does it add more zing? Would it lead to a harsher sound, much like I got when I tried out an SD Quarter Pounder P-pup in my first parts-bass? (In that particular case, it was too harsh, so much so that it completely overpowered a strong Super 55 J-pup. Ultimately, I had to go with something a bit more mellow.)

I know, I know…I'm asking using some pretty subjective, non-scientific terms, but I'm cool with it if I get some equally non-scientific feedback. ;)

Can't answer your question, but essentially it's one wide pole <O> allowing side to side string vibration compared to 2 small poles next to each other <o/o> catching both sides of the string vibration. So the gap with 2 is the big difference vs no gap with one larger pole. I'd guess the magnetic 'pull' on one larger pole would be more consistent w/o a gap, (resulting in a smoother response?) and with 2, there would be more side to side 'pull' from each magnet. How that translates to sound I don't know. The guy to ask is @Bruce Johnson - he would have an experienced opinion for sure.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Malak the Mad
I've always been intrigued by pickups with the smaller number of large pole pieces. That, combined with my love of a good P/J configuration, leaves me with a bunch of questions. For example, what's your take on their overall sonic "palette" and what do they have to offer that sets them apart from the more standardized pickups?

I have the same bass in Diamond blue .
This bass actually has a humbucker in the bridge vs a single coil Jazz pickup . It sounds nothing like a p/j.

The bridge pickup soloed is full round and thick. Very meaty yet clear. No loss in volume when soloed. This bass has a very smooth tone. Not at all hot or over wound in tone. Just warm, full and smooth with no mud.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Malak the Mad
Here’s my 75 with stock P and Novak split jazz pickup (higher output to partner well with the P). I didn’t decide to cut into the body, a previous owner did which gave me a cheap vintage bass. It’s a great player (A width neck - just like a jazz) and sounds fantastic.
 

Attachments

  • C15C1E8A-80ED-4BCE-98A5-F2636BA99EE3.jpeg
    C15C1E8A-80ED-4BCE-98A5-F2636BA99EE3.jpeg
    261.9 KB · Views: 36
  • AEFF9C76-6DC7-4402-9013-6DE3DEEC6098.jpeg
    AEFF9C76-6DC7-4402-9013-6DE3DEEC6098.jpeg
    293.4 KB · Views: 28
It is something, isn't it, that Victor Wooten fella playing a PJ bass? If nothing validated PJ before, Wooten sure did.

Late to the party, here are my two PJs:

1973 Fender Precision Bass
  • heavy ash body, maple neck with skunk stripe
  • "A" neck profile
  • crude 70s J route
  • Pat Wilkins body refinish
  • Lollar P pickup
  • Klein J pickup
  • KTS bridge
View attachment 903377


2013 Bluesman Vintage Eldorado PJ/JJ bass
  • alder, maple, rosewood
  • thin P neck profile
  • medium-heavy relic finish
  • Flying Mojo PreCBS-type PJ pickups
View attachment 903378

The new arrival:

Just one more: First impressions of my second custom Fodera bass, a Walnut Burl Imperial 4 Elite

IMG_7703-Edit-XL.jpg

IMG_7712-Edit-XL.jpg

IMG_7765-Edit-XL.jpg
IMG_7778-Edit-XL.jpg

IMG_7810-XL.jpg

IMG_7816-XL.jpg