• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Playing live and making mistakes

When I mess up, EVERYONE in the band stares and laughs. Then, a few songs later, the guitarist messes up and we all stare at him and laugh. The “repeaters” in the audience often catch the mistake and laughs along with us. Yeah, tough crowd, tough band members, etc. Don’t worry about IF you make mistakes but WHEN you will make them and how to handle it. We find humor in them.
 
Sometimes I surprise myself by getting through a song without making a mistake. Thankfully, a mistake for me is dropping a wrong note or two -- I'm never out of it for more than a measure, and usually not more than once in a song. In other words, I'm the only one who notices. I prefer to play with people who just laugh it off.

I used to play with a guitarist who made it very clear that he would NOT be embarrassed on stage by somebody else's incompetence. If anybody missed a note, he would shoot daggers across the stage. The guy was a tool and a hack. He made more cringe-worthy mistakes than anyone in terms of frequency and severity. I had to start eliminating songs from the list that started with a guitar intro -- the guy could never get the tempo or the notes right.
 
Writing a song about it this very minute. Plan to dedicate it to the drummer. "Mistakes, I've made a few, but I just smile, and blame them all on you..." Whaddya think? Seems you're a bunch of hacks if you make mistakes live, even more so if you admit to them on a public forum. I never make mistakes at gigs anymore. Like Bob Ross used to say: "We don't make mistakes, we have happy accidents." :laugh: Seriously, by spending 85% of my practice time creating novel sonic escape routes from quagmires, I've managed to camouflage the clunkers so a minimum distraction is noticed. That's the key, to minimize the impact and lessen the distraction. If the song continues without missing a beat, if (when) you do hit a clam it's easier to bury. There have been nights that I wish had a rewind button, but they went off relatively smoothly because of a good recovery system.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Big Shrek
I do little mistakes quite often because I focus on the show instead of the playing..I run, sing , tell jokes to my bandmates...

Two tricks : Don't stop playing and keep smiling! This things happen all the time.

My biggest mistake was one month ago when I played 4 whole bars in the wrong key at the begining of a guitar solo...When I noticed, I looked to the guitar player , smiled and I keep playing the whole chord progression (4 bars) and then I played in the right key.

Still I get compliments for that show LOL
 
  • Like
Reactions: Big Shrek
It depends on how new the material is. If it's the same old stuff we always play, I don't make many....rather than quantify it, I liked what a contractor told me --

"The difference between a professional and a non-professional is the professional knows how to cover his mistakes".
 
This is from my first show with this band. First song of our second set, the bass doesn't come in right away so I didn' notice right away. I left my amo on standby. Figured that out pretty quick. Still no sound. Turns out someone unplugged my bass. So you can see me desperately looking for the end of my patch chord. poopie happens, you just have to roll with it. Here's the video, where you can clearly see the red standby light.

 
A few things I learned about mistakes. Truth be told, I really hate making them, I'm often hard on myself, and I therefore do my best to keep them to a minimum.
Stay consistent and engaged in what you are doing. That’s the key for my playing.

This is one of the most important things I've learned about my playing. If I stay focused on what I'm doing, I can play as well as a classical musician. I've had many nights of no mistakes whatsoever, and while I'll admit it's not common, it's what I'm always striving for. 99.9% of the times that I flub, it's because I'm distracted. Throw a half naked super sexy girl dancing right in front of me, and my hands start to sweat. I wish I were joking, but I'm not. Not saying it's guaranteed flubs, but it's dangerous territory. I have to reconnect my brain, and keep my focus. Lots of other things can set me off if I engage them. Broken glasses are common at weddings, as are barefooted women dancing on top of them. That one can get me too. Interesting people, something on the bar TV, other problems I might be experiencing onstage, daydreaming - lots of things can cause a disconnect. Whenever I flub, I've realized it was one of those disconnects that caused it.

As far as making mistakes, I have 3 rules for myself (that I can think of right now, anyway :)) that I try to stick to:

1. No matter how bad I thought it was, it wasn't that bad: One of the first really high end shows I played was with a band I had no business being in, about 20 years ago. These guys were out of my league at that time, but I work hard and was able to fake it well. Songs were very complicated and intense, some ballads, with lots of time changes. We were playing a spot in NYC I always dreamed of playing, and the performance was being multi-track recorded for a live CD. I was terrified. I did well despite my rattling knees, but train-wrecked one important transition. About a week later I got the tracks of the gig and immediately zeroed in on my train-wreck. I was astounded! My train-wreck was a beautifully written tasteful line I just decided to add to the song :). It was in key, and it would have been impossible for anyone who didn't know the material inside out, to even know I had made a mistake. I tossed and turned a couple of nights over that flub, but feel I learned a lot from it. After that I started checking any time I could (when gigs are recorded) and it's always the same. For me, the mistakes are rarely what I make them out to be when they're happening. Part 2 of this is I've learned to forgive myself and let them go immediately when they happen. No big deal. Focusing on a flub will only cause more flubs cuz my focus will be out the window as quickly as if that girl were dancing in front of me.

2. Always work the flub into the tune as best as possible, and keep that Danny Partridge face happening: Gene Simmons taught me how to go WHOOOOoooooooooOM, and WHOOOOoooooooooOMs can be a bass player's best friend. They can steer you out of a brain fart, get you to the next note, and best of all - work as a foundation for pretty much anything the band could be doing. Depending on the speed, length, and articulation you can really work miracles with one of them. I also try to keep in mind something Victor Wooten drills home in his book. When flubbing, the most you can be is 1 note off from a note that will work. And I'll add that most of the other notes WILL work, even if it's a wrong one. Keeping this in mind helps me to be relaxed about whatever is going on, and getting right back to where I'm supposed to be.

3. Never project your own or anyone else's mistakes, ever: I think this is one of the things that separates the true pros from the wanna-bees. Although I've worked with lots of pros who still don't have it down. No matter what's going on onstage, never EVER give as much as even a glance at the offender, and never give as much as a glance at anyone else when the offender is you. I can't stress how important this is. 9 out of 10 times the band themselves will think a flub on our part was intentional if we show zero signs of a flub. And what's even more important is that 9.9 % of the times the flub disappears within a second of it happening. Nobody will remember, comment, or care. As soon as we acknowledge even the slightest of flubs, it becomes a mark on the chalk board. And often times band members are counting, often unconsciously. Make 5 flubs in a set that are acknowledged and at the end of the set the whole band knows you were messing up. Keep cool about it and you're much more likely to hear, "Great set!." I'll add that most musicians are more concerned about what they themselves are doing as opposed to what you're doing.

I'll add one more thing, that ain't a rule - but motivation to work towards making as few mistakes as possible. As most know, the bass player has the least forgiving instrument. A "C" guitar chord can blend in nicely with a "G" on bass, but a "C" on bass when the chord is a G changes the whole song :). Hate to quit on that note, but it is what it is. Drummers actually have a rough time too, but they can play whatever they want and never play a bad note.
 
I saw a study that said we think we are better at things than we actually are. Always stuck with me. I never let myself think I'm good at anything. Better at thing X and than thing Y, but never allow myself to say I'm good at one or the other.
 
I saw a study that said we think we are better at things than we actually are. Always stuck with me. I never let myself think I'm good at anything. Better at thing X and than thing Y, but never allow myself to say I'm good at one or the other.
If you're referring to the Dunning-Kruger effect, it also works the other way around. Which is how I feel sometimes.

On my last gig, a flub of mine turned into an impromptu bass solo... there's a first for everything. :\ At least no one gave me the stink eye.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Big Shrek
A few years back I saw The Flecktones in a pretty small venue and I witnessed Victor Wooten make a mistake. It was pretty obvious (to a bass player, my guitar player didn't notice). I forget the song but he was supposed to play and A but instead played a B. He laughed a little to himself while correcting it and Bela even cracked a little smile. I felt bad because I laughed a little too - not at his mistake but because it just confirmed that he is actually human and makes mistakes as well.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Big Shrek and dbase
If you run thru the clam bin, do it on a fast song: Half a chance they'll think it was supposed to be there on some busy line at high speed. S-l-o-w songs can be deadly, as there's nowhere to hide, and everything just hangs there in mid air. At least, you can wipe the egg off your face between verses . . . . . .
 
  • Like
Reactions: Big Shrek
Brings me to the song "Sunny" by Bobby Hebb... Verse 5 .. Bass should have hit a G, but it was something else. Always stood out to me since playing bass. I never understood why they left that on the track and published it anyway.



Because it was tracked live in a room with all the musicians. The performance was otherwise excellent; retracking the whole song and getting the same vibe and results from everyone involved just to fix *one* bum note would have been nearly impossible.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mr.Ace and dbase