• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Precision Bass dilemma

I play a Fender Highway One Jazz Bass for over 11 years and this is my main bass, but about 2 years ago I wanted a Precision Bass, which I got back then (a Japanese Fender), which is great, I love its simplicity and used the bass quite a lot, mainly for my alternative rock band (the Jazz Bass was more for my jazz band).

15111134_1302588606449970_5351735222847392149_o.jpg


But I wanted more, and I decided to order a high end P Bass (will not tell the name of the builder, but it was in the 2K range as opposed to my other two Fenders which are around 1k), which in the end I sent back because it had construction flaws which was not acceptable at all for 2K.

After sending it back I got another Japanese Fender for another 1K, which is essentially as my first one, but older (1997 as opposed to 2013), and I dig its colour and slight dings and ageing more. I just liked how it looks, and I bought it.

21083302_1724846740890819_6331427619276547127_o.jpg


Now I have two identical Japanese Fenders, and I do not need two, but I cannot decide which one to keep. They sound and play identical, the turquoise one sounds a bit too middy, but I am thinking to swap the pickup, but looks better to me and is older.

I wanted to sell the sunburst one when I got the high end P Bass, but it did not sell, and now I have two basses, and no high end P Bass.

Both basses are good, but I wanted a higher end P Bass, which went wrong, and now I have an extra bass. What are your thoughts on this?

Should I sell them both and go high end again, or rather look for a vintage Fender?
 
put flats on one and rounds on the other, and you'll see they're not at all the same anymore :)

edit: If you don't mind spending the money, put vintage voiced pickups with the flats and hot pickups with the rounds, and you'll be set for life!

compare:




If you're like me and don't like rounds at all, you can try out for the Phil Lynott/Steve Harris school of rock tones, with Quarter Pounders and Rotosound flats! that'll serve any rock purpose!
 
Last edited:
I can't imagine why you would want to sell two awesome basses in order to roll the dice on another expensive one. I mean, if it was ME and I HAD to sell one, I would keep the blue one and experiment more with different strings before swapping out the pickups.

But if it was ME, I would also keep the other one and put flats on it. (Disclaimer: I have six Precisions.)