The only sound that was even partially close to what I wanted was maxxing the Gain out.
Sounds like the amp was not your thing... thats cool.
Since reading this thread, I've really been playing with the Quilter EQ, and getting a lot of very cool sounds.
This amp is NOT for the tone tweakers, and not for the overdriven tube amp crew... at least IMO. This amp is all about gentle eq curves, and clean output.
... Which blows my mind because so many guys say the amp is "Tubey." -- What ever that means.
Tubey like my Hiwatt DR201 was Tubey. Of all the amps I've owned, this one reminds me most of the TunderFunk TFB800.
I see so many guys doing what the OP said, and -Maxxing the Gain-.
IMO, that is a mistake with this amp. You start to hear breakup and "harmonic" noise at that setting, but you are overdriving the compressor into distortion.
- Different thing from "tube breakup". Cool if thats your thing, but a little limiting if you ask me.
IME, if you set the master way up... like all the way up, it opens up a bunch of tone possibilities.
You can subtract EQ, and make up the volume loss with the Gain knob. I rarely set my gain knob past 11:00 on the dial.
For folks who want a "bright switch" kind of sound, put your master on 800, turn both tone knobs all the way counter clockwise, and set your volume with the gain knob.
For a total midrange sound, which is not that great sounding IMO, set the master at 800, the depth knob all the way counter clockwise, and the contour knob all the way clockwise. Then adjust volume with the gain... literally can't get more midrange than that.
Any-hoo... Max that master out, and see what you can dial in. The "Gain" almost becomes part of the tone stack - and not a "volume" thing.