I can agree on point 1, however I believe point 2 is the exact opposite of the truth.
I didn't say they were NOT cliched at all, just not overly so. I mean, every pop band is gonna have some cliches that they fall into. Its almost asking too much to have a pop band that is completely original. However, I do find some originality in Hayley's vocal melodies and phrasing that is refreshing IMO. There aren't too many out there that sound like her. But, there are a lot that wish they did.