• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Should I stay or should I go...? Problem solved - Mods please delete thread

Okay, so a bit of background...

I started as bassist for my current band when I was 12 years old. Always had other bands on the go but this was always my priority. We got good gigs, bad gigs, charity gigs, built ourselves up a damn good reputation, got screwed over and learned the hard way about the pros and cons of record deals. We stopped playing full time after 6 years on the scene, and that was 5 years ago now. We played a recent gig (a comeback gig) that we put on ourselves a few months ago. It came with its own problems but it mostly went smoothly.

So, my current predicament.
Late last year the singer (BL by default) got in touch with us in a group chat to say he had been asked about playing a wedding in September of this year and asked us if we were available. We all agreed that we probably would be, and that was the last we heard about it.

Fast forward to the present, and somebody who is going to the wedding asks if we are all ready. Ehh... What? I politely explain that I had no idea, as we never had the gig confirmed to us by BL or booker. No details of it, and none of the band has rehearsed. So I send a message in the group chat to ask about it, along the lines of "I'm assuming were not playing it as nothing has been confirmed, but are we?" To be told that we are. Short notice but okay. BL said we were probably only going to be a small part of the wedding so I reply that was a good thing, as I was worried we'd be playing our usual 3 hour set that we haven't played in 5 years, to be told "We are".

So I start to get worried at this point and realise that the wedding is now 2 weeks this Saturday. We will have no opportunity to rehearse, as the singer/BL is on holiday until a few days before the wedding. Guitarist can't make it over, so he needs replaced for the gig. Keys player has flat out refused to play it on account of the short notice and he only did our reunion show, so doesn't know any of our songs off the main setlist. Me and the drummer are very concerned and considering walking out too.

We also find out that the groom has been telling people we are playing for free because he's good friends with us, which is not true. I've been given a rough estimate of £550 For the whole band, which is about half of what we used to charge and isn't particularly worth me doing, as I'd get at least double my share of the cash if I worked that day. Drummers in the same camp as me.

So to sum things up, we are on 2 weeks notice with no real rehearsal for 5 years, we don't know the time, date or venue we are playing at as we haven't been told, and now know we are only earning a paltry amount for this.

My question is, do I play the gig, lose out on money from work and have the reputation of ruining the happiest day of someone's life because we never rehearsed, effectively killing the band and ensuring we never get booked again? Or do I go with my gut, kindly explain that I will not be made a fool of in a situation that everybody is uncomfortable with, and have the reputation as a quitter until I explain my exact reasons behind it which would leave folks more understanding of my situation?

Any suggestions, wisdom, idioms or carrots greatly appreciated.

-EDIT:

Over the last few days the situation has improved dramatically. The groom has always known the band, and has very kindly explained that it's not anybody else he wants, it's us. BL explained that it would only be 2, possibly 3 of the original band and this is why we aren't charging our usual amount, but he's happy with that. It's not going to be a high class day by any means, just a relaxed wedding dance and completely informal, so he's perfectly happy with our situation. Obviously I'd rather be on top of our game, but now I know the situation a bit better I'm a lot happier. I've received a *rough* set list and know most of the stuff on it, which is fine.

After originally quitting the gig entirely, I've now decided to do it. It really does pay to have good communication, and I feel a lot more optimistic than I did over the weekend.
 
Last edited:
Singer thinks he can pull it off solo.
Let him rent a karaoke machine and have a go.

This project died years ago, and unlike those SciFi films, you can't just pull off a dusty tarp and light it up.
You got along without them for 5 years; you've moved on.
If the other guys still want to play _after_ the singer's self-inflicted disaster, restart something with a new singer.
 
A band that plays every 5 years isn't a band, it's an occasional event. You're not ruining anyone's wedding. The "BL" did that all by himself by not following up on this. The wedding will be better served by a cancellation on the part of this band than it would be if a bunch of unrehearsed, twice-a-decade players try to provide entertainment. I would not even consider doing this, unless maybe the bride was my own mother or one of my very dearest friends. And if that were the case, I'd have known I was expected to be there.
 
You're not ruining anyone's wedding. The "BL" did that all by himself by not following up on this. The wedding will be better served by a cancellation on the part of this band than it would be if a bunch of unrehearsed, twice-a-decade players try to provide entertainment. I would not even consider doing this
^^^This pretty much sums it up^^^

By the way anybody know an appropriate way to message BL on his holiday to politely tell him I won't be joining them?
Contact him the way you would normally and say, “Sorry, but the lack of communication and organization for this gig have made me realize that it will be an unprofessional presentation, therefore I will not be participating. I suggest canceling, but if you decide to follow through, good luck…”. (Or something like that ;) )
 
I think you've answered your own question in the OP. It isn't going to go down well any way you go but I'd be sending the BL a polite refusal email. State the obvious and if he thinks it'll still be fine then be firm and bow out. If you meet the bride and groom down the track you can always buy them a coffee, sit down and explain what really happened because you can bet the BL will lay the blame away from himself. Yes they'll be scrambling for a replacement but that's not your issue to fix.
 
I also suggest that you pass on this one. The bit about the groom saying that the band is playing (3 hours!) for free ends the discussion, period. There were already too many negatives and uncertainties about this one-off gig to begin with.

Pass. This band is history, anyway, and the so-called band leader's conduct here gives you no reason whatsoever to re-join this unit. Let him sort it out.
 
I absolutely would not play the gig. I would, however, be concerned about what the singer may say to people, as he sounds like someone who will throw someone else under the bus without hesitation rather than take responsibility for the situation. You’re in a tough position. Whatever you decide, I hope it works out OK.
 
  • Like
Reactions: LBS-bass
play the gig, lose out on money from work and have the reputation of ruining the happiest day of someone's life because we never rehearsed, effectively killing the band and ensuring we never get booked again?
I'm going to vote against everyone else and say do this, as it will guarantee you never have this problem again. Just make sure BL pays you before the gig or you are never seeing the money.

Edit:
And you can bet money that the BL will blame you for not doing the gig if you pull out at this stage.
Although given you were asked if you were ready maybe there are already suspicions it will be a trainwreck?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Charlzm