I'll try not to repeat suggestions, except one (now two)
Pearl Jam - Elderly woman behind the counter in a small town (in case 'that old lady song' didn't get you there), Soon Forget (you know you want to), Brain of J, Given to Fly, Better Man
Sponge - Plowed, Wax Ecstatic (if you can really commit to this one its amazing)
For Squirrels - Mighty KC
Refreshments - Banditos
Seven Mary Three - Cumbersome (this is an all or nothing one too)
Lifehouse - Hanging by a Moment, Sick Cycle Carousel
Better than Ezra - In the Blood, King of New Orleans, Good
Green Day - Brain Stew & Jaded (you can't NOT play Jaded come on), 2000 Light Years, Road to Acceptance
Smashing Pumpkins - Everlasting Gaze, Stand Inside Your Love, Disarm, Zero
Radiohead - Electioneering, Paranoid Android (you would be amazed, if you pull this off, how well it goes down)
Presidents - Dune Buggy, Mach 5, Volcano, Lump, If you're going to do Peaches you can't half ass it either
Beastie Boys - Sabotage
Sets like these you can also bring in some out of genre songs that transition well with several 90s songs
Misfits - Halloween
Boston - Smokin (again, if you can commit to it it's great in the middle of a 3-4 high energy song run)
Alice Cooper - School's Out
Twisted Sister - We're Not Gonna Take It
Bon Jovi - You Give Love a Bad Name
MC5 (Presidents, Rage, every other band ever) - Kick out the Jams
And seriously, some of the Weird Al versions like Gump, Smells like Nirvana go over surprisingly well with the right crowd.
Pearl Jam - Elderly woman behind the counter in a small town (in case 'that old lady song' didn't get you there), Soon Forget (you know you want to), Brain of J, Given to Fly, Better Man
Sponge - Plowed, Wax Ecstatic (if you can really commit to this one its amazing)
For Squirrels - Mighty KC
Refreshments - Banditos
Seven Mary Three - Cumbersome (this is an all or nothing one too)
Lifehouse - Hanging by a Moment, Sick Cycle Carousel
Better than Ezra - In the Blood, King of New Orleans, Good
Green Day - Brain Stew & Jaded (you can't NOT play Jaded come on), 2000 Light Years, Road to Acceptance
Smashing Pumpkins - Everlasting Gaze, Stand Inside Your Love, Disarm, Zero
Radiohead - Electioneering, Paranoid Android (you would be amazed, if you pull this off, how well it goes down)
Presidents - Dune Buggy, Mach 5, Volcano, Lump, If you're going to do Peaches you can't half ass it either
Beastie Boys - Sabotage
Sets like these you can also bring in some out of genre songs that transition well with several 90s songs
Misfits - Halloween
Boston - Smokin (again, if you can commit to it it's great in the middle of a 3-4 high energy song run)
Alice Cooper - School's Out
Twisted Sister - We're Not Gonna Take It
Bon Jovi - You Give Love a Bad Name
MC5 (Presidents, Rage, every other band ever) - Kick out the Jams
And seriously, some of the Weird Al versions like Gump, Smells like Nirvana go over surprisingly well with the right crowd.