Spector really has been tempting me lately... I was sure my next bass would be a Ray, but now I'm doubting it. I really love that growly punch to Spectors. I've heard they're one trick ponies though... is that true? Would I be making the right choice by going Ray? Also, how does the neck width compare?
Depends on the style you play, do you dig in with your fingers, or do you have a lighter touch in general? The P/J set up is great, and the more you dig in the better the EMG PUPs respond, depending on your preamp.
That being said, I used my NS-2A today to go through a bunch of songs that require a vast array of tones.
Led Zeppelin - Ramble On - warm but aggressive tone
Santana - Black Magic Woman - thick and warm tone
Guns N' Roses - Sweet Child O' Mine - more modern and punchy tone
Brown Eyed Girl - warm, rounded tone
Some tunes I would favor the P pickup, some were a blend of P/J and also where on the bass I played - closer to the neck, fatter, warmer tone - closer to the bridge - punchier. This is true of all basses, but with the Spector you get the extra oomph and growl
I used my Rebop for songs like
Maroon 5 - Moves Like Jagger - modern, low punch
Black Keys - Lonely Boy - low end boost, not too articulated
Ben Harper - Steal My Kisses - warm, rounded with a touch of brightness
Green Day - Holiday - edgy, punchy
The Rebop is a different animal - but it still cuts through like a knife if you want it to.
The thing is, the notes sound so much clearer to me - and as one of my friends put it, after hearing the Spector - he said he could hear 'the outside edges of the notes' - there is a certain definition to the Spector tone, no matter what setting, it's there. I don't know how else to describe it, you just have to play one and see if it speaks to you.