Here's what
should be my last "shootout" post for a long while. I'm out of duplicate circuits/clones at this point! (Unless people want to gift me some Muffs/Rats/HM-2s...) Without further ado, my HM-2 shootout on
guitar.
As you can see, I have 9 HM-2s to shootout here. I did not try the Dunwich DIY HM-2, because I tried that when I first got it, and it definitely isn't my style on guitar. It is certainly optimized for bass, and I'll leave it at that. I'll try and be brief, because I'm definitely a better bass player than guitar player, and certainly pickier about bass dirt than guitar dirt. Also, I've found I pretty much always prefer straight HM-2 clones on guitar, and this shootout didn't change that. Here goes!
Notes on tones/goals/rig: I'm doing this for chainsaw. I'm not looking for versatility in guitar tones. While I can see how some of these would be used for other tones, I'm looking solely for that sort of tone, and not much variation on it. I always started with the same settings for each pedal (or as close as possible given different knobs etc.), which are my favorite settings on the OG. These settings are: volume as needed, EQ maxed, distortion 10:30. (I have found that in my experience, more distortion after this point only seems to increase the noise floor and offer no extra distortion. 10:30 allows me to get my preferred tone AND use a noise gate to avoid unwanted squealing etc.) After trying those settings, I tried to emulate that exact tone on each pedal as best as I could. My rig for this was an old Peavey Supreme head (because HM-2 + Peavey Solid State = Swedish Death Metal), a Peavey 412 MS cab from the same period, and my trusty Ibanez ARZ507 (7 string Les Paul copy) with Seymour Duncan Nazgul/Sentient Pickups. So high gain pickups into the head version of a Bandit - fairly similar to the old school Swedish death metal bands whose tone I'm trying to ape.
OG HM-2: You know it, you love it, nothing you don't know. I have the MIT version, which depending on who you ask is inferior to the MIJ. Of course, just as many people swear they're identical...
DOD Super American Metal: I found this to be slightly grittier, just a tad harsher in the treble, and with slightly reduced bass. Still, in a mix, this would be indistinguishable from the original. I found no compelling reason to deviate from my preferred settings on this one. I LOVE old DOD, and this pedal only confirms why. Hard to track down, but worth it if you want a slightly different HM-2 tone. I think one of the DIY kits allows this as a build option, but I can't really remember.
Arion Metal Master: More bass/low mids than the original, and slightly less harsh distortion. Still a solid HM-2. I had to reduce bass to about 3:00 to get similar tones as the OG, but I could totally see this being used for lower tuned HM-2 goodness. Can be a little muddy due to the extra bass, but not indistinct or anything like that. Pretty much all of the things I liked about this on bass make it a little tougher on guitar though. Still, totally usable, and if you want a beefier HM-2, this is the one to get. Plenty of volume on this one, with the knob being around 10:00 most of the time.
RockTek Metal Worker: I never really hear anything about this one, but I snagged one a while ago for like $30. Totally worth it! To me, this is later-era Entombed in a box (even though I know they got away from the HM-2). It's got more bass than the OG, and less treble, but not as much bass as the Arion. The distortion also seems looser and less aggressive than the others. The first time I plugged this in, I have to say that I was underwhelmed. It's not as aggressive as the OG. Today, however, I was pleasantly surprised. It really sounded great for a "low gain" HM-2. I never tweaked this one to get more gain and match the OG because I was enjoying the tone so much. This one seemed loudest, as I had the volume at 9ish most of the time.
Behringer HM300: Another clone that has been discussed to death. But, everything that you've heard is true - this NAILS the OG tone for about $25. Totally worth it if you want an HM-2. If I'm being picky, I think this is
slightly more treble-oriented and clearer than the OG, but I also think that could be component drift of the original after 30+ years.
Peper's Pedals HM-Too Many Clones: My favorite HM-2 for guitar. I'd been following this builder for a while, and then this popped up with Dismember's "Like An Ever Flowing Stream" artwork on it. Seeing as they're my favorite Swedish Death Metal band, and I wanted an excuse to try this clone, I HAD to get it. I wasn't disappointed. Just as raunchy as the original, with improved definition. It seems ever so slightly less abundant in the deeper lows than the original, but also seems less muddy, and isn't lacking lows by any stretch either. Almost like the lows have been shifted slightly, and are now more usable. Anyway, the best clone I've ever played for guitar, and this shootout confirmed it. I LOVE this pedal. It's the HM-2 tone I've always had in my head, and requires no tweaking. All of the modern accoutrements (true bypass, top jacks, etc.) just make this a complete win for me.
BYOC The Swede (built by Alchemy Audio): Another straight-forward clone, and currently my #2 for guitar. Bought used, so I can't verify the builder, but it has an Alchemy Audio sticker, so I assume it's Alchemy Audio. Very similar to the Peper's Pedals, but with slightly looser distortion and slightly less bass. Still, plenty of bass and distortion to go around, and reducing the highs just a touch with slightly more gain gets it back into balance EQ-wise. Considering you can pick this up for less than $100 used, and it has all the modern upgrades the original (and many other cheap clones) lacks, it's a great HM-2. I wish I could solder, so I could get this circuit and start tweaking.
Earthbound Audio Throat Locust: Another clone that I hear almost nothing about. I swear, I feel that almost no one owns this one or has reviewed it. Not sure why, either, as the builder is well-known and respected. I used to have two of these, but recently sold one to fund other dirt. Similar to my bass review, I found this best when NOT going for straight chainsaw. To get straight chainsaw, I had to reduce the mid control to about 4:00ish, and up the mid frequency to about 1:00. If I didn't do that, it seemed tuned slightly lower in the mids and had a cocked-wah tone built in. I actually think the lower tuning of the mids is one of the things that leads to its versatility. By opening up lower mid tunings, you can expand or change the peaks of the famous HM-2 EQ by either putting them closer or farther apart. I wasn't a fan of the cocked-wah tone, so I had to tweak it. Still, it can totally get the chainsaw tone by adjusting the mids. The distortion also seems slightly looser/splattier than the others, but not much. This is definitely a much more "open" HM-2 than the others, which may or may not be a bad thing. For my uses, I'm not looking for "open" tone on guitar, but it's not a negative by any stretch. However, I can't recommend this for straight chainsaw tones alone - other clones are cheaper and easier to dial in for that. But if you want other HM-2 tones, this is the clear winner. It's incredibly tweakable and can do chainsaw, but excels in "chainsaw-adjacent". If I had to make a wager, I'd say that the tone goal of this pedal was the song
"Throat Locust" by Tad, and the circuit board even has "Listen To Tad" engraved on it. It can definitely nail the lower-treble HM-2 tone as demonstrated in the song. (I have no clue if Tad actually used an HM-2 or not, but it seems like maybe they did? While I enjoy the songs I hear, I can't say I'm a fan of the band - if it weren't for this pedal, I'd never have heard of them.) If you have similar tone goals, give this one a go - it may be your winner.
Bear Amps Heavier Metal: I had to give this a go on guitar as well. It did NOT chainsaw at the same settings as others - the gain range is much more usable throughout its sweep unlike the original. To chainsaw this one to my liking, I HAD to have the gain on max. I also had the left toggle switch on modified - it was a personal preference, but it seemed to tighten the tone somewhat, and focus the low end slightly. Like my bass review, this one is all about the little details. I could get lots of chainsaw tones from it, and they were all quite good. But seeing as I'm not that picky for HM-2 guitar tones, it was a bit much for my guitar needs. It most certainly can chainsaw, and can do so quite well, but is more tweakable in its scope than I'd ever need for guitar. With both builder's tweaks engaged (both toggles up) I felt this was a high gain distortion pedal, and not very HM-2 like (much like my take on the Dunwich for guitar). Much like my bass experience, at higher settings of the quench knob, the pedal began to mute and lose distortion. I kept that knob at 9:00 or less to control the low end a bit - not that it was too much, but this seemed to change the amount of clarity/definition for the circuit. Again, just like the bass review, if you want to have ultimate tweakability of a chainsaw tone, this is your pedal. But if you just want to plug in and chainsaw, there are simpler, more affordable, and readily available clones.
Bottom line: All of these can "chainsaw". So if that's your goal, no problems for any of these. If you want no nonsense chainsaw - get the Behringer (cheapest), DOD (vintage, but hard to find and about $100 minimum), Peper's Pedals (excellent clone, but hard to find, based in New Zealand, I believe, and might be a kit, too), or BYOC (offered as a kit and occasionally pre-built). If you want more low end, get the RockTek or the Arion (both of which can be hard to locate, as I don't think either are made anymore). If you want tweakability, get the Earthbound (hard to find, and I'm not sure of the builder's status these days) or Bear Amps (actively building, but with a wait).
Well, I think that's it. Hope someone benefits from all of this, and I haven't bored all of you too much. Now I may be able to actually play bass! I think some Iron Maiden may be next on the "to learn" list. That or actually learning the
real bass riff under the solo during Metallica's "The Four Horsemen".