• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Stu Hamm Hears Vulfpeck For The First Time

I really don't appreciate when creative people rip on other creative people.

I agree with this. I would say not just "creative" people but more just fellow artists. I took Hamm's jokes as more that he just doesn't like those sorts of bands/types of music. Look up pretty much any thread on talkbass and it's a lot of the same that goes on here. People don't have any hesitation in letting everyone know when they don't like an artist on here. It's fair enough to not like all music but I just don't get going around sharing a negative opinion about artists without adding anything else of value to the post.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Goatrope
I agree with this. I would say not just "creative" people but more just fellow artists. I took Hamm's jokes as more that he just doesn't like those sorts of bands/types of music. Look up pretty much any thread on talkbass and it's a lot of the same that goes on here. People don't have any hesitation in letting everyone know when they don't like an artist on here. It's fair enough to not like all music but I just don't get going around sharing a negative opinion about artists without adding anything else of value to the post.
Yeah, exactly. It took me a long time, but I learned it's actually a lot cooler to just humbly say that something isn't for me, and maybe why depending on the situation and context.

I have enough experience with my own negativity to easily recognize that he's being a jerk and trying to smooth it over with "humor". Of course Ian and Sharon had little choice but to go along with it, though it seemed like Ian was making some effort to give Hamm a graceful way out of the hole he was digging for himself.
 
To be fair, sometimes the audience is just too dim to get the joke (or simply don't want to get the joke).
every great comedian that has ever walked this earth would disagree with you, barring language or cultural disconnects.

the construct of his "humor" was nothing complicated at all. It was disrespect and condescension with a very thin veneer of j/k.

I welcome you or anyone to explain what I'm missing and why it's funny. I'm wrong at some point every day, so I could be here too.
 
It's kind of funny to me that I can describe Vulfpeck's music and the Joe Dart signature Stingray in the exact same phrasing: take something that's great and strip it of everything that makes it great until it's exactly like everything else.

This made me laugh so hard I passed coffee out of my nose

…and note, I haven’t had any coffee in the last ~12 hours.
 
every great comedian that has ever walked this earth would disagree with you, barring language or cultural disconnects.

the construct of his "humor" was nothing complicated at all. It was disrespect and condescension with a very thin veneer of j/k.

I welcome you or anyone to explain what I'm missing and why it's funny. I'm wrong at some point every day, so I could be here too.
I don't think every great comedian would disagree with me, actually. Some humour does fly over the heads of some people, and some humour presents too much of an ideological or political affront certain people's beliefs for them to find it funny - even though plenty of other people may very well find the material funny.

By the way, I'm not referring at all to the video in question (which I don't think is particularly worthy of comment).
 
  • Like
Reactions: Root 5 and N4860
I suspect that Stu thought it would be funny to act like he doesn't like Rush. He's played on a couple of Rush tribute things so I suspect he's probably a big fan. Likewise Rage. He's shared a stage with Tom Morello at least once. "Chill out man." That's pretty funny.

He might have been wise to cut it at that point, but he decided to run it into the ground and I have to respect that. 😅

I think the constant cutaways to Sharon cracking up were supposed to convey that he was doing a bit.
 
  • Like
Reactions: FRoss6788 and N4860
I don't think every great comedian would disagree with me, actually. Some humour does fly over the heads of some people, and some humour presents too much of an ideological or political affront certain people's beliefs for them to find it funny - even though plenty of other people may very well find the material funny.

By the way, I'm not referring at all to the video in question (which I don't think is particularly worthy of comment).
I figured that you wouldn't agree with me, otherwise you wouldn't be saying the things you're saying.

I guess my bad for thinking that we'd be talking about the video that was posted.

I do think "Have you met Grace Jones" is funny, but not in a general sense, because very few people know the song you're referencing. It's ok though, because it's not negative or crapping on anyone.

Maybe you're trying to prove a semantic point? Would it be less contentious with you if I used the words "good joke" or "good bit" instead of funny? Maybe you'd like to chime in in a relevant way?

A situation where someone, or many people, laugh is not necessarily funny from a broad or general perspective. Millions of people currently walking this planet would laugh at a video of an old lady falling down stairs. That doesn't add up it to being funny.

I realize subjective descriptors can be tricky.

I just think it's valuable when people speak into crappy behavior, and I am thoroughly unconvinced that Hamm doesn't actually think what almost everyone thinks he thinks about the artists he's crapping on.

"that sucks hahahaha" doesn't do it for me and obviously doesn't do it for a lot of people.

It's not exactly Peter Sellers in "Being There" subtlety. He's just talking smack, and not in an interesting way that brings a redemptive quality to it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bass12
that's a woman and she has a name. Show some respect.
too many people have dumb ideas about what's funny
eww-disgusting.gif
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Swerve and andare
It's kind of funny to me that I can describe Vulfpeck's music and the Joe Dart signature Stingray in the exact same phrasing: take something that's great and strip it of everything that makes it great until it's exactly like everything else.
Eh, I'm pretty impressed by Dean Town and at his concerts it's probably the first time I've ever seen a crowd sing along to a bass part.

But if you've heard this guy do bass solos and can say you aren't impressed, well... I don't even know what to say to that. I'll never be the player that this guy is.
 
  • Like
Reactions: GregC
I’m a big fan of Stu Hamm but this could have been edited to allow him some time to come up with something better than that. Kinda lame.

There goes 17 minutes of my life I’ll never get back. 😐

Kind of defeats the purpose if they give unlimited time to come up with the perfect part. Its just meant to be a quick take and se what happens. Its not an album session.
 
Eh, I'm pretty impressed by Dean Town and at his concerts it's probably the first time I've ever seen a crowd sing along to a bass part.

But if you've heard this guy do bass solos and can say you aren't impressed, well... I don't even know what to say to that. I'll never be the player that this guy is.
There's a difference between technical prowess and artistic clout

6439457.jpeg

These are not the same
Parliament_Funkadelic_main.jpg
 
  • Love
  • Like
Reactions: Heiwa and FRoss6788