I've had a few of the SX SJMBs (two short scales I wound up reselling, which were uncomfortable for me to play, personally, but sounded great), and two regular scales, both of which I still own, and they all have/had certain characteristics that I love.
Yeah, the neck dive is a big drag (the second one I have is a spankin' new one, and really isn't any better than my '08), but I have to agree: at this price point, you're not going to do any better. Even the Squier Jags won't serve you too much better. The pickguard issues must've skipped all of the ones I've owned, or it just doesn't bother me.
I'm going to be swapping out the pups and the bridges, which, as someone did point out, will essentially cost more than the basses themselves, but these things are hellacious canvases on which to work. Not wanting to sound snotty, but I'd have reservations about hot-rodding a $1,000.00 Jag bass. Not so with my SXes.
I've also got an old SX Jazz fretless 5er that I'd stack up against pretty much any Fender I've ever owned or played. These guys make really decent lines of affordable basses that you can leave be or soup up as you like.
Great review, Troy. Thanks for sharing this!
- DWL